Dan made some good points...
OK..I will stand corrected in a couple aspects...
First and foremost by a great point that Dan made...if the garnish doesn't fit in with your flavor, color, texture and presentation on the plate, then why are you putting it there to begin with...??????????? If it taste like crap, why destroy your plate, I don't care how pretty it is...
When I was at the International Gourmet Festival in Puerto Vallarta, the restaurant that sponsored me had a sushi chef that did some AWESOME garnishes....bland flavored so that it blended in with any flavors he put on the presentation, these were merely decoration, but accented no flavor that went along with the plate. Is that wrong? No, I don't really think so, if the garnishes held a flavor that counter-acted the flavor of the plate I would definately say yes, but his garnishes were beautiful and neutral...this was his expression of his art and not a bad thing because they did not interfere with the flavor and texture of his original idea...
As far as painting plates, I have done my good share of them also, making coulis' out of everything from yellow peppers to beets to golden beets to chipotle peppers to color infused chocolates...were the plates beautiful and did they accent the flavors of the dish, most definitely...will I do them today, not too often...
I let the presentation of the food speak for itself, the mixture of colors in my rice pilaf for instance to blend with the paleness of my protein, to the vibrancy of my sauce accented by the mixture of colors and textures of my vegetables...
This is why I choose not to garnish anymore, it is not because I do not like garnishes or do not think they work, I do it for the simplicity of who I am and what I do...
Great insight Dan...sometimes we forget the cool stuff we did before we changed our point of view...
Just another artist expressing his craft,
Chef Michael Hayes
http://restaurantedge.com/index.phtml?catid=47