Wow, old thread.
Well, since it's open......
I recently ordered a cake from a local bakery for my daughter's 14th birthday.
She wanted zebra stripes.
The girl who took our order was very upbeat and positive, leading me to believe that this was going to be a beautiful cake.
Myself, I was expecting fondant, as not many people posses the proper piping skills to do nice zebra stripes.
What we received was pretty horrid.
It was a white cake with uniform wedges and squiggles around the perimiter, no wavy lines widening and thinning as they go, as do zebra stripes.
And the piping wasn't smooth.
It looked like the cake was invaded by cancerous slugs.
The owner was out of town but I finally reached her a week later.
She defended the cake, saying that they focus on flavor, not looks, and they don't use fondant due to the poor flavor.
She also said her decorator does beautiful free form work, but can't do "special" orders, as our zebra stripe apparently was.
Okay, I get that flavor is most important, but to use that as an excuse for ugliness?
I'd rather have fondant (preferably real) and a good tasting cake beneath than a great tasting cake that looks like a 5 year old did it.
Unless I commission the cake from a 5 year old of course.