By whom?

Every rating I've seen downgrades Mastercook because it does not conform to Windows appearance and operation but it has one of the best F1 help systems in existence, if you pay attention, you don't need the manual. In fact, I cannot think of a single rating that accurately reports what Mastercook is capable of doing.
I've tried them, I still use Mastercook. Why? Because it does what I want.
It is YOUR choice, not mine.