I already have an 8" Zwilling (JA Henckels) Four-Star Chef's knife which I use for overall general every where use and I have little problem with it being shared around the kitchen.
What I'm looking for is a 10" Chef knife before my apprenticeship starts; a personal use one, one 'only' I can use at home or work. A 'Dream Knife' of sorts, one to dominate my knife collection, but I'll also get a Victorinox (I can't find a better value good-quality knife than their's) as a spare to use or lend to others.
The short list so far is as goes:
- Zwilling Professional S (31021-261)
- Wusthof Trident Classic (4582)
- Messermeister San Moritz Elite (E/2686-10)
- Thiers-Issard Sabatier ('Four-Star Elephant')
... for me the Zwilling is the 'safe' option, I've got a 6" from a model series I can't quite put a name on but it's similar to a Pro S in a narrower German blade. The Wusthof Trident seems to be the most expensive of the bunch and the Sabatier, the one that needs a bit of hunting for.
I'd prefer a knife with a riveted handle with a squarer profile, it somehow feels better, fits my hands just right and firm. The more curvy moulded style handles are quite varying, one model might fit someone else's hands perfectly but not so in mine.
I'm leaning towards more of a French blade for a Chef's knife this size since I have the 6" Zwilling for tighter jobs.
The carbon steel Sabatier kinda worries me a bit if I get a water spot or something, how to get the knife shiny again. I mean would health inspectors frown on a non-shiny knife.
I've tried a few Global knives at work including the G-2 and another large knife G-17 I think it was, while the one piece design is nice, wonderfully sharp when honed perfectly and lightweight. But the handles just don't feel right except the GS-7 which a rather unconventional shaped paring knife but it feel 'perfect' for all the jobs I've used it for (I'm trying to get one for myself). If I don't feel comfortable with the Cook's knives, so Global isn't on the cards for my 10" knife search.
Opinions welcome to help me learn and find the right knife for me. Oh and another thing is my budget range is AUD$100-300 (USD$80-240).
[I wonder whether the forum administer can move my thread to the "Cooking Equipment Reviews" section because it seems a more spot to put.?]
What I'm looking for is a 10" Chef knife before my apprenticeship starts; a personal use one, one 'only' I can use at home or work. A 'Dream Knife' of sorts, one to dominate my knife collection, but I'll also get a Victorinox (I can't find a better value good-quality knife than their's) as a spare to use or lend to others.
The short list so far is as goes:
- Zwilling Professional S (31021-261)
- Wusthof Trident Classic (4582)
- Messermeister San Moritz Elite (E/2686-10)
- Thiers-Issard Sabatier ('Four-Star Elephant')
... for me the Zwilling is the 'safe' option, I've got a 6" from a model series I can't quite put a name on but it's similar to a Pro S in a narrower German blade. The Wusthof Trident seems to be the most expensive of the bunch and the Sabatier, the one that needs a bit of hunting for.
I'd prefer a knife with a riveted handle with a squarer profile, it somehow feels better, fits my hands just right and firm. The more curvy moulded style handles are quite varying, one model might fit someone else's hands perfectly but not so in mine.
I'm leaning towards more of a French blade for a Chef's knife this size since I have the 6" Zwilling for tighter jobs.
The carbon steel Sabatier kinda worries me a bit if I get a water spot or something, how to get the knife shiny again. I mean would health inspectors frown on a non-shiny knife.
I've tried a few Global knives at work including the G-2 and another large knife G-17 I think it was, while the one piece design is nice, wonderfully sharp when honed perfectly and lightweight. But the handles just don't feel right except the GS-7 which a rather unconventional shaped paring knife but it feel 'perfect' for all the jobs I've used it for (I'm trying to get one for myself). If I don't feel comfortable with the Cook's knives, so Global isn't on the cards for my 10" knife search.
Opinions welcome to help me learn and find the right knife for me. Oh and another thing is my budget range is AUD$100-300 (USD$80-240).
[I wonder whether the forum administer can move my thread to the "Cooking Equipment Reviews" section because it seems a more spot to put.?]








