or Connect
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

ceramic knives?

post #1 of 21
Thread Starter 
Hi! I was wondering what you think of ceramic knives. I have only seen pictures of them so have never handled one. Are they any a good, or are they just a joke?
Thanks for any input!

canadiangirl:cool:
post #2 of 21
They are very sharp and stay that way quite a while.

They are brittle--easily broken if dropped or you pound on them from the side as I do mashing garlic for example. Or chipped if you hit bone while butchering or carving.

And you have to send them back to the factory to be sharpened.

If you have the money and don't mind the down time while they're off being sharpened once a year or so, you'd probably enjoy them.

Phil
post #3 of 21
Thanks Canadiangirl and Phil,

I also wanted to know that.

Luc H
I eat science everyday, do you?
Reply
I eat science everyday, do you?
Reply
post #4 of 21
Thread Starter 
Thanks so much for the info! I guess I will have to consider all that before I buy one since I can be hard on my knives sometimes.
One other question I have is are they heavy?
Thanks again!

canadiangirl
post #5 of 21
no they are very light knives. I like to use them for tomatoes and other slippery surfaces, but for mincing and such, I just get scared that I will break them! I've already chipped my mom's twice! She got it because Ming uses them. She's a sucker.
Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. - GM
Reply
Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. - GM
Reply
post #6 of 21
Thread Starter 
Is there a specific brand that is supposed to be "the best"?:crazy:

canadiangirl:blush:
post #7 of 21
I have a small Kyocera paring knife I love. The very tip end has snapped off, but it's still a good knife. I'm not sure I'd purchase any more of them, though. This one was a gift. :)
Moderator Emerita, Welcome Forum
***It is better to ask forgiveness than beg permission.***
Reply
Moderator Emerita, Welcome Forum
***It is better to ask forgiveness than beg permission.***
Reply
post #8 of 21
Hi!

I had the same thing happen with a small ceramic paring knife - the tip cracked off. You're right, the knife still performed well, but I had a heck of a time trying to find the piece that had cracked off. It was kinda like having a small razor blade loose in my kitchen! I finally found the piece embedded in the sole of my shoe. Just thankful I was wearing shoes and that I'd managed to keep the dogs out of the kitchen.

The experienced turned me off to the ceramic blades nd I won't get another one.

Good luck with your decision!

-Mary
post #9 of 21
I bought one, a paring knife, from Williams Sonoma. I broke it within a week.
I am staying with steel, as I see a lot of disadvantages, and no positives.
post #10 of 21
I own a Kyocera Ceramic santoku which I love. Haven't had problems with chipping and such, and I think they come with a warranty.
post #11 of 21
Oooh! Let's talk about the ceramic peelers! I bet those would be fantastic and a less likely to break.
Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. - GM
Reply
Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. - GM
Reply
post #12 of 21
I use my kyocera peeler for making  plantain chips, works great!
post #13 of 21
if we're talking peelers, I love my Kuhn Rikon. (not ceramic) i used a ceramic and it was nice, but this is better. ceramic is interesting, but steel is better on the line and at home... and just as sharp/ sharper if you choose wisely and maintain it properly.
post #14 of 21
I also have been using both a kyocera peeler and also small paring knife for about 2 years. They get used almost daily
Both are still razer sharp, same as when they were new.
The peeler makes a very thin peel, which is great except if you have really "bumpy" carrots, in which case I use a metal peeler.

Definitely I agree with others that they are great for the right fruits and vegs (my wife doesn't like skins on fruit and I use the peeler to easily remove skin from ripe peaches and pears.. no problem); BUT, I only use the paring knife on soft items like tomatoes; anything that requires "chopping" or any force whatsoever like carrots, celery, or twisting, I use steel.

For the right use they are fantastic, but definitely they are limited and you certainly still need steel knifes for any type of twisting motion (like peeling an onion) or hard chopping.

Come to think of it, the paring knife mostly I use for tomatoes and fruit.
post #15 of 21

I have also been curious about ceramic knives for a while.  Finally, I bought one from an online auction site for less than $20 w/shipping.  It's a 6" blade and is very light.  My main purpose of this knife is use with fruits and veggies.  The sharpness, wow, this thing is crazy sharp, the blade just glides through all the veggies I have tried so far.  Then a quick rinse and clean under the faucet and put back on the top shelf, I don't want my kids or wife using it, too sharp and fragile for them.  I really like mine so far, and for less than $20 why not try one yourself? 

post #16 of 21

Ok, so here's the thing. If you are a home cook, who is only going to cut veggies and fruit with your knife, and you can find a good deal: go for it.

 

IF you are a professional

IF you want to cut meat/fish/shellfish/misc

IF you are going to use it for more than a few months

IF you like to be able to shapen your own knife

IF you are not going to baby it

 

Don't bother to buy one. Despite the common belief, they do get dull, and not as slowly as you'd like to believe. They also shatter (as in to pieces.). I had the misfortune of dropping a ceramic knife and having it shatter like glass. They chip, and you can't sharpen it out yourself. Waste of money.

 

If you want a high quality knife that will stay sharp, get high-carbon japanese knife.


Edited by Igannon - 5/11/10 at 10:06am
post #17 of 21

Yes to almost all of what Igannon said --I just don't understand the meat/fish thing.  Nevertheless, +1.

 

I'm surprised ceramic knives came up at all... again.  You don't see much written about ceramics anymore, nor do you see them marketed very much either.  It appears to be an idea, as Victor Hugo might have said, whose time has passed.

 

There are a lot of problems with ceramics.  Iggy got a few of them.  From my own viewpoint, one of the biggest is that they aren't made in sizes large enough to be a useful go-to knife. 

 

The biggest though is that they are so very fragile.  They pretty much come with a Broken Tip Guarantee

 

They appear to be pitched for people who can't sharpen a knife (even though ceramics do dull eventually).  But I don't see being limited to a paring knife for everything, especially one that needs to be babied, as a good solution.  Certainly not for anyone with decent knife skills.   

 

By the way, ceramic knives can be sharpened at home with decent skills, patience, and good diamond stones (like DMTs).

 

BDL

What were we talking about?
 
http://www.cookfoodgood.com
Reply
What were we talking about?
 
http://www.cookfoodgood.com
Reply
post #18 of 21

I had a Bokar utility knife that I used for about 10 years mostly at home. It was as sharp as the day I bought it when I dropped it and it broke. I used to use it for fruits and veggies as it wouldn't make them turn brown like some steel knives do. I miss it. I agree with Iggy about the Japanese knives. That's what I use at work.

post #19 of 21

 

I had a Bokar utility knife that I used for about 10 years mostly at home. It was as sharp as the day I bought it when I dropped it and it broke.

 

Probably just a typo -- if so, forgive the correction -- but it's Boker, not Bokar.

 

If you got 10 years of frequent use without any wear at all, you're the exception to the laws of physics then.  Ceramics do get dull.  They don't get dull as fast as steel knives, but they do get dull.  They are also prone to chipping.  Further,  they are problematic to say the least when it comes to sharpening. 

 

I dropped it and it broke is one of the other MAJOR drawbacks. 

 

A third is the absence of adequate sizes and any real variety in profiles.  They're pretty much limited to what the French call office and very small chef's.  They're office is useful when you want a small knife, but small chef's are non-starters as far as I'm concerned. 

 

Fourth, good ceramics are very pricey. 

 

I used to use it for fruits and veggies as it wouldn't make them turn brown like some steel knives do. I miss it.

 

I don't understand the separation of "fruits and 'veggies'" from other food.  Also I find keeping and maitaining special purpose knives for very common tasks to be a pain.  The why of it is beyond me.

 

The off color is caused by one of two things.  Either your knives are crushing rather than cutting or there's some sort of chemical reaction with the blades' steel alloys.  It's not any sort of leap to conclude your other knives are either cheap carbons (SK4, e.g.) which haven't been properly patinated or neutralized (as with baking soda); or, more likely, they are simply dull. 

 

I've used old French carbons forever -- most of them since when they weren't old and neither was I.  The rare instances of the browning you describe only occurred when I already knew the knives were well past time to sharpen.

 

Ceramics are something like Cutco in that they are knives for people who don't really "get" the whole "sharpening is part of owning knives" bit.  But, to paraphrase Robert Knowles, they're entitled to cutlery too.

 

2 more cents,

BDL

What were we talking about?
 
http://www.cookfoodgood.com
Reply
What were we talking about?
 
http://www.cookfoodgood.com
Reply
post #20 of 21

Hey Boar. Yes it's Boker. I got mine for free. When I talk about discoloration I'm referring mostly to avocados apples limes and lettuce. I find that even with a very, very sharp carbon steel knife they tend to discolor when sliced. They didn't with the Boker. My knives are all extremely sharp by the way. I have never heard of "patinated or neutralizing" them. How exactly do I do that?

post #21 of 21

"Patina" is the artist's name for passivation.  In other words, a very thin, stable layer of oxidation which protects metal from reacting with its environment --  including preventing further oxidation.

 

It's become popular to "force" a patina on new carbon-steel (i.e., non-stainless) knives in order to prevent them rusting and from reacting with food.  To do this, soak the knife in some sort of oxidizing agent -- prepared mustard, hydrogen peroxide, vinegar, etc.; remove the knive from the soak, and wipe it just enough so that you can see the surface; allow the knife to continue to react to the agent until it looks like it's achieved the desired amount of patina; rinse the knife thoroughly to stop the reaction; wipe down thoroughly; allow at least a day for the surface to stabilize, then dip in a dilute solution of baking soda (NOT washing soda), to completely stop the reaction, and rinse and wipe again.

 

Mustard patinas are very interesting -- the patterns look almost like wootz or Damascus.  Mario Batali did his Misno Sweden knives with mustard -- you may have seen his gyuto on the last Iron Chef.

 

Another good method for patinating/passivating is to scour your carbon knives with Bar Keeper's Friend.  The oxalic acid in BKF will cause the surface of your knives to oxidize not too long after you've cleaned them.  After they've achieved the proper level of patina you can do the baking soda thing. 

 

Speaking of baking soda, another way to make carbon steel less reactive is to "neturalize" it by scouring it with baking soda.  The knives will still develop a patina but it won't be dark.  Instead it will be the dull, silver glow of properly maintained tools.

 

BDL

 

What were we talking about?
 
http://www.cookfoodgood.com
Reply
What were we talking about?
 
http://www.cookfoodgood.com
Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Cooking Knife Reviews