ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food and Cooking Forums › CookBook Reviews › The Good Cook Book Club
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Good Cook Book Club

post #1 of 36
1/22/01 at 6:39am
Thread Starter 
Who all belongs to the Good Cook Bookclub? I have been with them for 3-4 years now and love it! They run so many great deals and I can't think of how many almost free books I have recieved from them. If you are trying to build up a cookbook collection, this is definately the way to go.
Reply
post #2 of 36
1/22/01 at 11:17am
Hey Pete, what's the source? How do I get info for membership? I've been wanting to get in something like this.
Reply
post #3 of 36
1/22/01 at 11:42am
I got their brochure in the mail a couple of weeks ago, and was wondering about it myself. The address is: The Good Cook, Operated by Bookspan, Camp Hill PA 17012-0001. I was a member of another book club but abandoned it in favor of my local independent bookstore, which I loyally support. I'd be interested in knowing the advantages of joining this, versus ordering directly from my local guys. If the advantages are significant, I'll consider joining.
Reply
post #4 of 36
1/22/01 at 8:02pm
Thread Starter 
The Good Cook is not a full, comprehensive catalog, but they always have the latest, hottest cookbooks and many more. You can usually find their brouchers in foodie mags. such as "Food & Wine", "Gourmet", "Food Arts". It is a typical club. You get 3-5 books for free (just shipping), then you must by 2 more books in 2 years. Their prices are great and they always seem to be running deals like buy 1 book at club price and get all other books you order for 50%, or every book is worth double points. After you buy your required books you start to earn bonus points which you can use to get free books. I love it. But don't expect to find some of the more serious trade books. It is geared towards foodies not chefs, though I always find something I want in it.
Reply
post #5 of 36
1/23/01 at 10:58pm
I'm a four year member! The bonus points work out great! And the deals they have like the 50% off of every book after buying one at regular club price. You just have to keep up with the reply forms or call them and tell them you do or don't want the "book of the month"....but it's a good club.
Reply
post #6 of 36
1/24/01 at 12:12pm
Ahhhh, thanks for reminding me. Gotta get my reply card in the mail before feb 1.
Reply
post #7 of 36
1/30/01 at 10:36am


I'd love to join. I got Bon Appé*** and there was a add for it. Enjoy 4 books for 1$ each. Some idiot had tore up the card. I exchnaged my copy at the store. Except now the add said Enjoy 3 books for 1$ each. Same magazine different offer.

In small caracters on the add it said members accepted in USA and Canada, offer varies slightly in Canada. I found the website and emailed them asking what the difference was. I get a reply telling me sorry the offer is not valid in Canada. Couldn't believe it. I think I'll send it in anyway and will see what happend.

The url is: http://www.thegoodcook.com/goodcookcgi/home
Reply
post #8 of 36
1/30/01 at 2:06pm
I think it's hysterical what the site's software did to Sisi's citation of Bon Appetit! Thanks for the caution, foodnfoto. With that knowledge, I'll shop at my local independent bookstore.
Reply
post #9 of 36
1/30/01 at 3:10pm


How come it didn't do the same thing when you named the same magazine?
Reply
post #10 of 36
1/31/01 at 12:56am
Thread Starter 
You can also phone in to cancel the selection of the month. Also, I don't find shipping to be that expensive. I still save quite a few dollars by ordering from them.
Reply
post #11 of 36
2/7/01 at 12:44pm
I joined my wife (read: I joined myself a second time) but I haven't heard back and that was over a month ago. I think they are on to us.
Reply
post #12 of 36
2/7/01 at 3:55pm
Of all the things one could be addicted to, the best has to be cookbooks. I hope to be addicted to them for the rest of my life. One thing is for sure, I will never join cookbook anonymous. :D

[ 02-07-2001: Message edited by: Sisi ]
Reply
post #13 of 36
2/7/01 at 9:13pm
I'd have to agree it is an addiction! Once I got interested in cooking (not an easy thing for me to do :mad: ) I found so many books I just had to have that they are taking over the place! :D
Reply
post #14 of 36
2/7/01 at 10:49pm
I totally agree Sisi, the anticipation, the opening, oh is there pictures...great instruction....ingredients, methods.....
Reply
post #15 of 36
2/8/01 at 4:42am
I seem to remember them telling me that you could only have one membership per address(somehow they recognize single family dwellings,perhaps apartment buildings or an address like 121a or b works). So, I signed up my neighbor to get the free books, then cancelled to she wouldn't be bugged.
Please don't spend the grocery money on cookbooks - therein lies the addiction (been there, done that. This is fun to talk about our "addiction" though -

[ 02-08-2001: Message edited by: LoriB ]
Reply
post #16 of 36
2/13/01 at 7:30am
I have been a member of The Good Cook book club for a year now. I absolutely am addicted, although I have a problem with returning the cards on time. I just send them back.
Reply
post #17 of 36
3/8/01 at 7:41pm
Two quick questions:
1) What does the Cook Book Club charge on average for shipping and handling (I notice they don't say on their site or in the magazine ads)

2) It looks like the web site has the best sign up deal. You get four books for $1 each, with only 2 more to buy. The strange thing is, that some books, like the Professional Chef, or French Laundry do NOT say they count as 2 selections on the web site (whereas they do count as 2 if you order through a magazine). This would seem to be the best way to sign up if you wanted these books (can anyone confirm whether this is true?) I was able to add the above 2 books to my cart, as well as 2 more books. I didn't complete the order, but it seems like it would have worked. Any opinions?
Thanks for the help
Reply
post #18 of 36
3/9/01 at 6:29am
This is a great way to stock up on cookbooks for a lot less money than buying at B&N or Borders. I love this club!
Reply
post #19 of 36
3/16/01 at 11:19am
Iza,

Chances are they will ignore you.

They ignored me! :eek:
Reply
post #20 of 36
3/17/01 at 4:47pm
Pooh,

I'm starting to feel ignored but I am not ready to give up yet.
Reply
post #21 of 36
3/21/01 at 11:01am
Too funny, Iza! :D

ChezMichelle,

I love "The Making of a Cook". Can't put it down either. It's my favorite reference book!

[ March 21, 2001: Message edited by: pooh ]
Reply
post #22 of 36
3/21/01 at 4:52pm
Michelle,

I got a card saying they were out of the mini mixer, the gift for joining and another one saying they were out of one title. So far no other books though. Did you received your other books with the cards or did they come later?

Thanks!
Reply
post #23 of 36
3/22/01 at 5:19am
Hi Sisi:

Got your e-mail!

I think it's their "subtle" way of refusing, even if they say the offer is available in Canada. I'll give it another shot any way. This should be amusing!

Thanks again.
Reply
post #24 of 36
3/22/01 at 1:52pm
Don't sweat the mixer. It barely has enough power to mix air. Mine was given away at a yard sale.

L
Reply
post #25 of 36
3/22/01 at 4:24pm
You guys are after my own heart! Or at least my stomach!
I looooove cookbooks, and the worst part now, is that I collect cake books and cookbooks. In English, and (cause I can read Thai) in Thai! Craziness. I too, am a member of the Good Cook Club. By the way...What were your free choices and 1/2 price one, if you went for that?
Here are mine...
The Cake Bible
Great Cakes
The Pie and Pastry Bible
Cupcake Cafe
and I bought for half price...
Perfect Pastry ;)
Reply
post #26 of 36
3/28/01 at 6:17pm
I’m in! I got two of my books today. My third book should be shipped this week.


To answer your question Valerie, when I decided to join I thought I should get books that covers areas I am less familiar with, so I ordered:

Vegetables by James Peterson
Sauces by James Peterson
Salute to Healthy Cooking by The French Culinary Institute's

I still have to choose two other books since one of my choice that counted as two is not longer available. No mixer either, but I am not really worried about that one. Now I have to decide what books I want. I would love suggestion. I could get the James Peterson’s book on Fish & Shellfish but I’ve never seen it. Hate to buy books I haven't seen. Has anyone had a chance to look at it?

How do you like Great Cakes Valerie? I can’t believe I would order yet another dessert book. I have so many already.

What about How to Bake by Nick Malgieri or The Wisdom of The Chinese Kitchen? So many choices, it will be hard to decided. :confused:


Pooh the club has an address in Ontario, if you are interested, just send me a message and I’ll give you the details.
Reply
post #27 of 36
3/28/01 at 10:30pm
Sorry Iza, I haven't checked it out yet. It sits on my shelf, hoping for a moment of my time!
Reply
post #28 of 36
3/29/01 at 8:32am
Thank you, Iza.

Found it!!

;)
Reply
post #29 of 36
4/12/01 at 9:02pm
I just succumbed to their relentless pursuit. I will get 4 books for $1 each + shipping. Even if the shipping is $28 I am still getting the books for $8. Not a bad deal. I think I have to buy 2 more books over the next year. I think it's a nice way to build out my referrence library.
Reply
post #30 of 36
4/14/01 at 7:22pm
You’re right, It is a hard offer to resist, What books did you choose Kyle?

I still have two free books to choose. Problem is I can not make up my mind. François Payard’s Simply Sensational or David Lebovitz’s Room for Dessert.?? Hmmm I have quite a few pastry and dessert books, might be better to find something else. Chinese or Italian maybe?? At this rate I’ll still be trying to make up my mind next month... :confused:
Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: CookBook Reviews
ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food and Cooking Forums › CookBook Reviews › The Good Cook Book Club