i know it's silly about my question because it's quite simple and probably everyone know, but here goes what the different between broth, stock and consommé ????? and thx sooooooo much for answering :):):)
ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food and Cooking Forums › Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion › difference between stock, broth and consomme???
Join Now
Be a part of the community.
It's free, join today!
Featured Sponsors
Recent Reviews
-
I love this knife and have used it daily since i got it from a friend about 3 years ago. I also have the 20 inch but im much more comfortable with this one. my only gripe is because the blade is...
-
I have learned and made many delicious and delicate recipes. Any recipes here will make your man/men happy
-
It is a very handy pastry book however the recipes measurement uses large quantity. This make it difficult for home cook. Nonetheless I enjoy reading and some of the professional techniques I...
-
We got this as a wedding gift and used it several times of the years. I have recently been using it quite a lot and have debated replacing it with a new bigger compressor model, but may just...
-
I have been waiting for years for a good, reliable and easy to use iperEspresso machine. Now I can have my favorite illy espresso every morning. I highly recommend to get 'capresso froth pro' to...
difference between stock, broth and consomme???
post #2 of 8
8/3/08 at 11:08am
- oldschool1982
-
- Retired Chef
- offline
- Joined 6/2006
- Posts: 1,295
- Reviews: 2
- Select All Posts By This User
Any questions see this conversation of just a couple days ago. Not trying to be a pin head but what Culinary school did you attend that did not cover this in your first year?
- HIME
- Just Graduated From Culinary School
- offline
- Joined 1/2007
- Posts: 122
- Select All Posts By This User
i study in Indonesia and china so our first language is not English, so sometimes i'm not really sure about my english vocabulary when reading english recipe books. sorry :talk::talk::talk:
post #4 of 8
8/3/08 at 12:54pm
- tessa
- Professional Chef
- offline
- Joined 9/2007
- Location: Auckland New Zealand
- Posts: 587
- Select All Posts By This User
hime do you have an english translator they are a great help , a lot of the students in my school have them which help them translate in to chinese or what the language is that they speak
you must read every thing , and talk to as many people as you can in english , that way you get to understand it better and learn more
Stock is liquid that is made from boiling bones and veges together for a longish period of time , it is the base for all soups, sauces etc.
a consomme is a very clear delicate soup that is garnished in different ways and takes lots of love and care to make it what it is . Its normally a clarified soup
a broth is the next step up from a consomme, in that it is generally thicker with more body and texture in the soup
both consommes and broths are light gentle soups
you must read every thing , and talk to as many people as you can in english , that way you get to understand it better and learn more
Stock is liquid that is made from boiling bones and veges together for a longish period of time , it is the base for all soups, sauces etc.
a consomme is a very clear delicate soup that is garnished in different ways and takes lots of love and care to make it what it is . Its normally a clarified soup
a broth is the next step up from a consomme, in that it is generally thicker with more body and texture in the soup
both consommes and broths are light gentle soups
- HIME
- Just Graduated From Culinary School
- offline
- Joined 1/2007
- Posts: 122
- Select All Posts By This User
thxs so much it clears it up thxs, btw do you have recipes how to make chicken broth so far i just have consommé and stock , thxs :)
post #6 of 8
8/3/08 at 1:52pm
- Ninja_59
- Cook At Home
- offline
- Joined 5/2004
- Location: Montréal
- Posts: 372
- Select All Posts By This User
Heres an excellent translator
SYSTRAN - Online translation, translation software and tools
Hope it helps you
SYSTRAN - Online translation, translation software and tools
Hope it helps you

post #7 of 8
8/3/08 at 5:02pm
- boar_d_laze
-
- Former Chef
- offline
- Joined 2/2008
- Location: Monrovia, CA
- Posts: 6,902
- Reviews: 19
- Select All Posts By This User
Nothing's cleared up. You think you're asking about cooking, but you're asking about how English is used in the kitchen. Unfortunately, it's not used consistently.
A "stock" is a clear liquid made by simmering other ingredients in water until their flavors are extracted and transferred to the liquid. There's no requirement of meat. Many stocks are entirely vegetarian. Stocks are not served, but are used in the kitchen to make soups, sauces and as an ingredient in other dishes. Because stocks are a step along the way, they are usually under seasoned. A rule of thumb is that a stock should be bland enough so that when it is reduced by 50%, it is still not well seasoned. Fumets (fish stocks) are an exception, not because they are well seasoned, but because they usually cannot be reduced by 50% without becoming bitter and unusable. There are exceptions, though. Stocks are used and reserved after straining. That is, they are clear.
"Broth" is a very tricky word, because it has so many meanings. It can mean a "stock," it can mean the liquid component of a stew, and it can mean a soup. Broths, are usually fairly clear, but sometimes they are cloudy. For instance a stock with an egg beaten in, is a broth.
A stock can be made a broth or soup simply by adding enough salt to make it palatable. Alternatively, fresh aromatics may be cooked in the stock and either discarded after they have given their flavor, or barely cooked and kept as part of the broth/soup. Whether a broth is a stock only, or simply the liquid part of a soup, you already have many recipes.
"Consomme" is the one well defined term in the group. A consomme is a highly clarified stock based soup. Typically the clarification is done by defatting, straining and finally an egg white raft.
BDL
A "stock" is a clear liquid made by simmering other ingredients in water until their flavors are extracted and transferred to the liquid. There's no requirement of meat. Many stocks are entirely vegetarian. Stocks are not served, but are used in the kitchen to make soups, sauces and as an ingredient in other dishes. Because stocks are a step along the way, they are usually under seasoned. A rule of thumb is that a stock should be bland enough so that when it is reduced by 50%, it is still not well seasoned. Fumets (fish stocks) are an exception, not because they are well seasoned, but because they usually cannot be reduced by 50% without becoming bitter and unusable. There are exceptions, though. Stocks are used and reserved after straining. That is, they are clear.
"Broth" is a very tricky word, because it has so many meanings. It can mean a "stock," it can mean the liquid component of a stew, and it can mean a soup. Broths, are usually fairly clear, but sometimes they are cloudy. For instance a stock with an egg beaten in, is a broth.
A stock can be made a broth or soup simply by adding enough salt to make it palatable. Alternatively, fresh aromatics may be cooked in the stock and either discarded after they have given their flavor, or barely cooked and kept as part of the broth/soup. Whether a broth is a stock only, or simply the liquid part of a soup, you already have many recipes.
"Consomme" is the one well defined term in the group. A consomme is a highly clarified stock based soup. Typically the clarification is done by defatting, straining and finally an egg white raft.
BDL
post #8 of 8
8/3/08 at 5:42pm
- oldschool1982
-
- Retired Chef
- offline
- Joined 6/2006
- Posts: 1,295
- Reviews: 2
- Select All Posts By This User
HIME,
I did not understand that you were looking for the English translation of the items but instead thought you were asking what the tangible difference was. I also wasn't implying that your questions were less than "on the level" but since we just discussed this is why I provided the link.
I'm sure that trying to adapt recipes from one language to another like your native tongue from English can be quite a task. Yet as BDL stated there are many inconsistencies. Most of the terms we use are still in the language of the country in which they originated.
With that said there is a distinct difference between stock is what it is and a base. Broth is not an English word (or an Americanized one at that) for stock since broth is ready to eat and requires no additional ingredients to flavor it. Consommé is made from stock, is seasoned for final consumption but is clarified using a raft (or other method) to provide a crystal clear (with some color in most cases) soup that is minimally garnished with additional underlying, complimentary or contrasting flavored ingredients.
I did not understand that you were looking for the English translation of the items but instead thought you were asking what the tangible difference was. I also wasn't implying that your questions were less than "on the level" but since we just discussed this is why I provided the link.
I'm sure that trying to adapt recipes from one language to another like your native tongue from English can be quite a task. Yet as BDL stated there are many inconsistencies. Most of the terms we use are still in the language of the country in which they originated.
With that said there is a distinct difference between stock is what it is and a base. Broth is not an English word (or an Americanized one at that) for stock since broth is ready to eat and requires no additional ingredients to flavor it. Consommé is made from stock, is seasoned for final consumption but is clarified using a raft (or other method) to provide a crystal clear (with some color in most cases) soup that is minimally garnished with additional underlying, complimentary or contrasting flavored ingredients.
Return Home
Back to Forum: Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion
ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food and Cooking Forums › Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion › difference between stock, broth and consomme???
Currently, there are 191 Active Users
(11 Members and 180 Guests)
Recent Discussions
- › PLEASE HELP! LIVE LOBSTERS - Throw them away? 25 minutes ago
- › Calling All Food Experts! 25 minutes ago
- › More Flavor 41 minutes ago
- › Granola 49 minutes ago
- › Irish Food? 1 hour, 17 minutes ago
- › Chinese New Year Street Food in Honolulu 1 hour, 58 minutes ago
- › expanding horizons 3 hours, 41 minutes ago
- › I hate Vegans (cooking)........!!!!! 3 hours, 42 minutes ago
- › Dessert Ravioli Help 4 hours, 1 minute ago
- › 10 Superior Ales of The British Isles 4 hours, 40 minutes ago
View: New Posts | All Discussions
Recent Reviews
- › Shun Classic 8-Inch Chef's Knife by Pirate-chef
- › Pastry: Savory and Sweet by Shin Louis
- › The Professional Pastry Chef: Fundamentals of Baking and Pastry,... by Shin Louis
- › Donvier 1-Quart Ice Cream Maker by jhop
- › FrancisFrancis Y 1.1 iper Espresso Machine by jkun
- › Victorinox Cutlery 10-Inch Curved Cimeter, Black Fibrox Handle by boar_d_laze
- › Spiced Right: Flavorful cooking with herbs and spices by KYHeirloomer
- › Royal Coffee Maker Modern Copper Vacuum Coffee Brewer by boar_d_laze
- › Bodum Eileen 8 Cup French Press Coffeemaker, 1.0 l, 34-Ounce by boar_d_laze
- › Breville BCG800XL Smart Grinder by boar_d_laze
View: More Reviews
Recent Articles
- › Traditional Bologna Bolognese by MARGCATA
- › Basque Cod Fish Brandade by MARGCATA
- › Irish Soda Bread by MARGCATA
- › Turkey: Kasar Cheese by MARGCATA
- › Cuban & Mexican Tamales: by MARGCATA
- › Sushi and Sashimi by MARGCATA
- › Sukiyaki by MARGCATA
- › Shirataki by MARGCATA
- › Thistle Family: Cardoon Root by MARGCATA
- › Shichimi Togarashi by MARGCATA
View: Recent Articles | All Articles
Home | Reviews | Forums | Articles | Galleries | My Profile
About ChefTalk.com | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 ChefTalk.com Inc. is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map
About ChefTalk.com | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 ChefTalk.com Inc. is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map




