› ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food & Equipment Reviews › Cooking Knife Reviews › Need help with boning knife
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Need help with boning knife

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
I have been using a paring knife for boning but I found some change under the sofa cushions :-) and have decided to buy a real boning knife. The problem, because I have had no experience with them, is which to buy. I don't mean brand, but rather type.
There is of course the regular European type which we all know.
There are three Japanese types I have found
And another Hankotsu that is very large and heavy. Forget the name, but not really interested that one.
Any advantages/disadvantages in the three types that you have noticed with hands-on use? Recommendations?
I will be mostly deboning chicken.



Oh, I almost forgot. Of the European type there is a flexible one and a stiff one. I understand the flexible one is good for removing silverskin, but does this detract from it's ability to debone?
post #2 of 7
I bought the traditional flexible / German style - it is really 'just the right tool' for many jobs.

chicken I wouldn't put among them - certainly it will work but perhaps you may not get the bang you expected. they work best / shine at their task around and through heavy joints. pork/ham, beef.

silver skin is an interesting case. I often reach for the boning knife - but primarily because I keep the point sharp/sharp/sharp. the point is what you need to "get started" on the silver skin issue. if my 8" slicer is in top shape (the points go blunt between stone sharpening....) that actually works better because of the longer stroke with a blade flat available.

your mileage is apt to vary ! <g>
post #3 of 7
If you're really doing almost exclusively chicken, a honesuki is essentially purpose-built for the task. But they can be expensive, what with import fees and all that. Myself, I'd go for a long, heavy paring knife, which is basically what a honesuki is (there's more to it than that, but that's the point). That way it's useful for a range of things. As already noted, the long, flexible boning knife is primarily useful for larger meats and arguably for fish, and if you really have little need for this -- and as a home cook, you're probably right -- you won't get a lot of mileage out of one.
post #4 of 7
These questions cover an immense amount of ground in terms of knife design, knife technique and their interrelation.

Let's start with the last. At the risk of being obvious, the "right" knife for a given task isn't always the best choice for a given user -- even for that task. And it gets fuzzier from there.

Now, the first. There are three principal types of Japanese design boning knife: honkotsu, honesuke, and garesuke. The popularity of the shapes depends somewhat on purpose and somewhat on region. Honesuke and garasuke have very triangular shapes as a result of their wide heels. They're used primarily for chicken and pork. The honkotsu is shaped most like a traditional European boning knife profiles (desosser and fillet), is most popular for boning beef, and is most popular around Hyogo and Osaka.

Before going further with the profiles, let's get some butchering terminology down as it applies to chicken. Breaking down means cutting into serving pieces. Breaking means splitting the back bone, keel bone, or any of the other main bones. Jointing means separating the pieces at the joint.

A garasuke is a heavier version of a honesuke -- and usually longer. Garasuke and honesuke are not meant for removing bone in the western way, but for cutting through it. The Japanese like to chop the knuckles off the bones, cut the breasts into pieces across the ribs, and all sorts of "chopping" cuts we don't use very much in the west. From a design standpoint these profiles are not particularly good choices for jointing chicken into the cuts we think of as normal (half-breasts, thighs, legs, wings, supremes, quarter-breasts, etc). Certainly though, you can make either work well if you've a mind to do so. They're also not great designs for taking the meat from the bone to make boneless thighs. For that you want a knife with a lot of radius right at the tip, so you can keep the handle up as you cut next to the bone. The best choice is probably a petty; second best, perhaps a European boning knife. (It really doesn't matter with a breast, the meat comes off so easily.) But again, if you keep your honesuke or garasuke sharp they'll do the work almost as well as anything else. Sharp always trumps.

The honkotsu's blade profile sort of falls between the slender desosser style Americans think of as "boning" knives, and the slightly wider filleting style. It's much heavier than either European knife, and has a much wider handle. If you're comfortable using a European style boning knife, have the technique, and so on, it will do the same things in pretty much the same way. The Japanese profile is maybe a bit more useful for "frenching" and a bit less for the kind of intricate work required to take a lamb leg and hip bone, out of a sirloin/leg. Hard to say.

Some European boning knives can be difficult to sharpen because they're made out of fairly thick stock and have a narrow profile without much grind. In other words, they're shipped thick at the edge. Most sharpeners, even (what passes for) professional sharpeners (these days), don't know how to sharpen a good edge on that kind of knife. (More about this later.) Honkotsus are made of even thicker stock, but there's so much grind on one side (very right-handed is standard) they're faily easy to sharpen the first few times as long as you've had some experience with asymmetric edges.

You also asked about flex in European knives. Generally, stiff is preferred for larger mammals, and flexible for fish, poultry and small mammals. Flex is more useful when the knife is pressed against the board, then anything else. Sharp kinves will cut through (or at least into) bone before bending enough to follow a complicated shape. Curved knives make it easier to do slicing and steaking without hitting your knuckles against the board. Straight knives are easier to control for intricate work.

I was trained to do light boucher work when I had a job at a big deal French restaurant called the Blue Fox in San Francisco in the early seventies. I use the same sort of knife now as then -- a medium flex, carbon steel, Sabatier desosser. The current knife is a Thiers-Issard Elephant Sabatier.

The best way to keep the European style knives sharp is to thin before sharpening. Sabatier carbon will hold a 15* edge against a lot of abuse, so I sharpen a 10* bevel, then a 15* edge over that (15*/10*) -- and a little more acute than that at the tip.

Too much polish is counter-productive in a knife that sees so much raw, red meat; so I usually stop at a soft Arkansas -- the equivalent of about 1500# JIS, although sometimes I take it all the way up to a surgical black Arkansas (about 4,500# JIS). 2500# JIS would be close to ideal. Once sharpened, the knife maintains fairly well on a steel.

Because they're so asymmetric, the Japanese profiles don't usually steel well. That's really unfortunate in a knife that bumps up the board and bone so often.

My feeling is that all in all the European styles are better suited for European style work, and that they maintain better as well. However, knife purchasing isn't necessarily about pure practicality; and even if it were different people like different things. There's no best, only most comfortable.

Hope this helps,
post #5 of 7
Thread Starter 
Thank you BDL, it helps enormously. I was debating on the honesuki cuz it has a neat shape. Stupid reason, I know. I think the best bet for my use would be a standard European boning...ala Wustof. Cannot find any carbon ones. Since getting my Misono Carbon gyuto, I have fallen in love with carbon. Not that important, I won't be breaking down 20 chickens a day. Once a week maybe. Just need a new toy.
Again thanks. You are very kind to take so much time.

post #6 of 7
If you've fallen in love with carbon and want European-style, get Sabatier, choosing the lines BDL suggests.
post #7 of 7
For what it is worth, early in my career I had both styles of European boning knives in my case. I wound up reaching for the stiffer ones the vast majority of the time. Now days, I use my Chef's knife for deboning, filleting, and butchering chicken. Over the years, it has become such an extension of my hand, that it feels natural, even for what appears to be intricate work.
Wisdom comes with age, but sometimes age comes alone.
Wisdom comes with age, but sometimes age comes alone.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Cooking Knife Reviews › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food & Equipment Reviews › Cooking Knife Reviews › Need help with boning knife