New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

***** Top Chef: Las Vegas ***** - Page 4

post #91 of 124
11/25/09 at 12:07pm
So do you think that Brian shouldn't have helped him? Do you think he should have not shared information and possibly won himself? I believe that even if Kevin had not used that cooking method he would've found something else to do perfectly.
Reply
post #92 of 124
11/25/09 at 2:31pm
No, I think Brian should of helped him and he did. My point is that the contest doesn't bring professionalism into the judging which is a big part of being a top chef. Brian was very professional and helped Kevin out.

I don't think Kevin would of one in the time alloted if Brian would not of helped him.
Reply
post #93 of 124
11/25/09 at 5:06pm
So do you think that Brian shouldn't have helped him?

Not at all. What I was saying is that there's no question in anybody else's mind that Michael most emphatically would not have. And not only because it's a contest. Judging from his total behavior, I don't believe he'd have taught the technique to somebody who worked in the same kitchen. The man is totally self-centered, and believes he's the only serious cook in the world.

I don't think Kevin would of one in the time alloted if Brian would not of helped him.

I'd have to disagree. Look at the record of Kevin's wins and near wins. What I think would have happened is that he'd have gone in a different direction, and, perhaps, still have won.
Reply
post #94 of 124
11/25/09 at 5:28pm
I agree. Kevin is not as charismatic as the Voltaggio brothers, but he's more consistent. He's won more challenges than anyone and just about everything he puts out is executed perfectly. In this day of food fads, gimmicks, and tricks, it's a brave man that consistently wins on seemingly simple food. I have to believe that it's not nearly as simple as it appears on the screen.
Reply
post #95 of 124
11/25/09 at 7:37pm
At the beginning of the challenge, they said the contestants were supposed to create a "Bocuse" dish. I know what the Bocuse D'Or competition is, but I don't understand what they meant by a Bocuse dish. A certain kind of food, or serving style, or just something worthy of that competition? Was it referring to those big oval platters? Can someone enlighten me, please.
Reply
post #96 of 124
11/26/09 at 8:34am
Any one taking wagers for the top two? My picks are Brian V and Kevin.
Reply
post #97 of 124
11/26/09 at 10:37am
but I don't understand what they meant by a Bocuse dish.

I believe they meant something in the spirit of the Bocuse d'Or---that is, perfectly executed, perfectly presented, and, ultimately, tasting good. Keep in mind, with a challenge like that, the flavors had to balance not only within each dish, but also between the three dishes.

Not an easy thing to do, period. Throw the time constraint in on top and wow! It's like a dancing bear---the wonder isn't that he's so graceful, but that he can even do it at all.
Reply
post #98 of 124
11/27/09 at 12:56pm
I think a "bocuse" dish is something you would know if you followed this kind of competition on a yearly basis. There are probably unwritten rules followed that we know nothing of. My idea is that there has to be some kind of new techniqued developed, or something really innovated such as what the guest judge described: a protein within a protein within a protein.
Reply
post #99 of 124
12/1/09 at 1:34pm
Barring some sort of unprecedented cooking catastrophe I think Mike and Kevin will definitely make the finals so who'll be next to go, Jen or Brian V?
Reply
post #100 of 124
12/1/09 at 3:15pm
Thread Starter 
i think jen will get kicked off tomorrow...
Reply
post #101 of 124
12/1/09 at 5:08pm
Is it time for another episode? Already? But it's only been 2 weeks since the last one!
Reply
post #102 of 124
12/2/09 at 1:19pm
^Right...in all likelyhood, we'll have to wait at least another 2 weeks for the finale
Reply
post #103 of 124
12/3/09 at 10:16am
Thread Starter 
looks like her run is over... should be interesting... clearly michael voltaggio is the best out of all three (in my opinion), however im not sure who will win... maybe kevin since he is the most consistent?
Reply
post #104 of 124
12/3/09 at 1:06pm
I also think that Michael is the favorite going into the finale, but I'd like to see Kevin win since I personally prefer his style.

Yes, the Voltaggios make really complex, exquisite meals, but I find that when it comes to great food, often times it's like Miles Davis said, "Less is more." If I remember correctly, the few times when Michael tried to make more simple food, he failed to execute.
Reply
post #105 of 124
12/10/09 at 3:32am
Thread Starter 
the verdict is in...

:peace:
Reply
post #106 of 124
12/10/09 at 4:53am
Disappointing. If they were to base their decision on who cooked the tastiest food most consistently throughout the show they would have picked Kevin. If they were to base their decision on merely the final meal they would have picked Brian. But how they came to this decision I don't understand. Looks to me like their favorite was picked out all along.
Reply
post #107 of 124
12/10/09 at 7:00am
Thread Starter 
overall he was the best. at least in my opinion. however kevin seems to have been the most consistant, but hes not marketable along with the fact that me makes comfort foods which do not have that sex appeal that some ppl look for.
Reply
post #108 of 124
12/10/09 at 7:07am
I think they all won in my opinion. Kevin said it best when he said that on any given day each of them could of beat the other two since they are all that good.

This was the best season yet I do hope they continue to get highly talented chefs on the show and avoid the Jerry Springer type show.
Reply
post #109 of 124
12/10/09 at 8:36am
Unfortunately, Kevin choked last night...I think he got a little frazzled with his unlucky draw with the sous chefs. However, I didn't understand how the judges made their final decision either. I thought they said that Kevin won the mom's dish round with his chicken skin on squash puree while Michael's broccoli puree was inferior, Michael won the mystery box round, Bryan's venison beat out Michael's squab, and Bryan's dessert was better than Michael's poorly executed and dry cake.

To me, that sounds like Bryan won 2 out of 4 courses. Did I mis-hear the whole judges' discussion?
Reply
post #110 of 124
12/10/09 at 8:57am
KCZ that is exactly what my wife and I thought. Either way I am making my reservations soon to visit Bryan and Kevin's restaurants!
Reply
post #111 of 124
12/10/09 at 12:15pm
One thing to understand with all these competitions is that we don't get to hear the bulk of the judges discussions. In fact, they are intentional edited to give us the wrong idea, so that the announcement comes as a surprise.

If you think this is misleading on Top Chef, compare the judges' discussion we hear on Chopped with their final decisions. You have to wonder if they and we were watching the same competition.
Reply
post #112 of 124
12/10/09 at 3:51pm
Thread Starter 
i agree completely... i hope the ppl at top chef peruse the webz and see this because i am sure we are not alone... this is by far hands-down the best season yet.
Reply
post #113 of 124
12/11/09 at 6:17am
iconoclast, it was so nice to see the chefs helping each other out and acting decent towards each other. I found myself wanted all of the last four to win not just one.
Reply
post #114 of 124
12/11/09 at 12:55pm
It was definitely the best season yet. I'm sure Michael, Brian, and Kevin all have loads of success coming their way.

As for the judges' final decision, Michael's dishes are definitely the most "artistic," so if you're looking at cooking from that angle, he's definitely the winner. No matter how you feel about the judges' final decision, nobody can deny that these three finalists all deserved to be there.

IMO, the season finale should be longer. This way we can see more of the judges' discussion (who cares if there's a surprise or not...it's the finale, if you're not hooked by this point then you never will be) and more importantly, more of the cooking.
Reply
post #115 of 124
12/12/09 at 6:07am
Thread Starter 
agreed, there was a great deal of camaraderie.
Reply
post #116 of 124
12/13/09 at 3:59am
I do agree that Michael's dishes were the more inventive and artistic. However, I don't think I'd enjoy working in his kitchen! He always seemed to operate from a sour grapes perspective, and certainly didn't show any great management skills when working with other people. There was a post a while ago about the judges not judging on personality issues - but I think they do take it into consideration. The first season, I think with the woman chef who was so bossy in the kitchen lost - the judges all listened to the former contestant sous chefs who worked with her in the final; and another season - Marcel,maybe? The same thing. The judges all listened to what transpired in the kitchen during the finals. This time, though, they did seem to be judging on the food alone.

I remember Tom saying one time that the title of chef not only means cooking skill, but the ability to manage people and actually run the kitchen. I totally agree.
Reply
post #117 of 124
12/13/09 at 6:21am
Thread Starter 
i would not mind working with him or anyone similar (eg: gordon ramsay etc.) i am not there to make friends i there to make food, and make a success out of my career... as long as i am able to take away something from the experience it is all worthwhile.
Reply
post #118 of 124
12/15/09 at 2:09am
The challenge is never equally balanced at the end and regrettably Kevin drew the short stick with the Sous Chef's this time. He failed to manage his staff properly, became frustrated and ultimately failed. That's un-fortunate but I think he has a lot of raw talent with out the benefit of the work experience that the V brothers have. I think we will hear more from Kevin in the years to come.
IMO the right Chef won. In the end this was the best season yet and the show seems to be gaining credibility.
I would gladly work with any of them. No doubt both of the V brothers benefited from the time they spent working with Charlie Palmer.
Reply
post #119 of 124
12/15/09 at 1:41pm
Very good points, DuckFat. We should keep in mind that as a result of one of those last few challenges Kevin will be competing in a huge international cooking competition this coming year.
Reply
post #120 of 124
12/16/09 at 3:30am
Kevin has a chance to try out for the team. I'm a big fan of Kevin. You have to appreciate a young Chef with that much talent. However that type of cooking is not his forte. I do think he will still learn a lot from the mentoring he will likely receive and the opportunity to compete for a spot on the team.
Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home