I was wondering, many people say olive oil is healthy but is cooking with it the same healthy as eating it raw?
ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food and Cooking Forums › Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion › Cooking with Olive Oil Healthy?
Join Now
Be a part of the community.
It's free, join today!
Featured Sponsors
Related Forum Threads
- Canola vs Extra Virgin Olive Oil Last post on 3/14/11 at 1:25pm in Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion
- infused olive oil fresh vs dried Last post on 10/18/10 at 9:39am in Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion
- Strong Olive oils Last post on 4/21/11 at 3:55am in Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion
- Olive Oil Last post on 7/20/10 at 7:05am in Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion
- Olive Oil Last post on 5/15/10 at 6:06am in Q&A Forum With Mario Batali
Related Articles
-
Oil Cured Olives
Edited on 2/16/10 | Contribute to this Article
-
Myths About Olive Oil
Edited on 2/16/10 | Contribute to this Article
-
Moroccan Olives
Edited on 1/21/12 | Contribute to this Article
-
Arbequina Olives
Edited on 1/21/12 | Contribute to this Article
-
Ligurian Olives
Edited on 1/21/12 | Contribute to this Article
Recent Reviews
-
I bought one of these just for making osso buco. I found myself using it for a lot more than just that. I make tomato sauce in it, chili, any excuse I have to bust it out, I do. I absolutely...
-
I have always loved Indian food but like many who have never travelled to india itself i have often wondered how authentic the Indian food i have eaten actually is. This book has convinced...
-
One of my first internet knives. Great blade. I mean *great* but the handle was a bit weird. Right now it just sits at the bottom of my knife kit.
-
I've owned one of these for over 3 years now, using it daily. I've never had to sharpen (grind) it, just an occasional run along a fine steel, and it's held a wonderful edge for everyday prep....
-
I purchased my first Smart grinder nine months ago. I was thrilled with it and thought I had found the perfect grinder for a French press grind that would change settings quick and...
Cooking with Olive Oil Healthy?
post #2 of 14
4/29/10 at 11:14am
- French Fries
-
- At home cook
- offline
- Joined 9/2008
- Location: France and California
- Posts: 1,676
- Select All Posts By This User
No. Raw oil is always healthier than cooked oil, and that's true whatever the type of oil, olive or other.
post #3 of 14
4/29/10 at 3:50pm
- Jock
- At home cook
- offline
- Joined 12/2001
- Location: San Francisco
- Posts: 1,315
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
OK, so what does heating the oil do to it that makes it less healthy? I know that some quality is lost in heating (that is, the uncooked oil just tastes better) but what health benefits are lost?
post #4 of 14
4/29/10 at 3:59pm
- French Fries
-
- At home cook
- offline
- Joined 9/2008
- Location: France and California
- Posts: 1,676
- Select All Posts By This User
I honestly don't know the details... but when we got our newborn we read a lot of books on nutrition and one important point was to give him raw oils - not cooked.
AFAIK heating/cooking any food (so including oil) breaks down its nutritional value.
AFAIK heating/cooking any food (so including oil) breaks down its nutritional value.
post #5 of 14
4/29/10 at 6:23pm
- thegardenguru
- Professional Chef
- offline
- Joined 12/2009
- Location: Pismo Beach, CA
- Posts: 95
- Select All Posts By This User
Heating causes loss of available nutrients (as expected) contained in oils, including fat-soluble vitamins such as E and the phytonutrients that give oils their characteristic colors, smells and flavors.
Heating oils can cause formation of free radicals, highly reactive molecules that can damage the oil further by triggering unwanted oxidative reactions.
Formation of unwanted aromatic substances (such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons or PAHs) in the oil that can increase our risk of chronic health issues including cancers.
Joe
post #6 of 14
4/29/10 at 10:45pm
Hello,
I think olive oil is good for health.In these days many kinds of olive oil is presents,all are good.so don't worry about it.just use freely.www.maldari.com/
I think olive oil is good for health.In these days many kinds of olive oil is presents,all are good.so don't worry about it.just use freely.www.maldari.com/
Points taken, but are you perhaps referring to fried oil? I could imagine why that would not be good, even for olive oil. But I really am not sure whether eg. baked cooked olive oil is bad...
post #8 of 14
4/30/10 at 2:43am
- chefedb
-
- Retired Chef
- online
- Joined 4/2010
- Location: West Palm Beach/ Florida
- Posts: 3,638
- Select All Posts By This User
Fried Oil/ ?? You really can't use olive oil for deep or high temp pan frying, as the smoking point is to low. It would probably burn or ignite and cause a fire.
post #10 of 14
5/1/10 at 1:51am
- siduri
- At home cook
- offline
- Joined 8/2006
- Location: Rome, Italy
- Posts: 2,770
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
I used to fry with extra virgin oil when the kids were young, just because as i understood it, all cold-pressed oils are free of chemical additives that get modified under high heat conditions. I never used a deep fryer, I did stuff like croquettes or potatoes or battered or breaded vegetables and stuff like that, in a frying pan with oil to cover. I used high heat, the stuff seemed to brown easily and not to absorb too much fat, and it never ignited, ever. I didn;t fry very often and i had a free supply from my inlaws who knew someone in the country who produced it. My understanding is that in cooking (not frying) the extra virgin oil is best, - it might lose something but doesn;t add anything harmful.
I think the term "healthy" is interpreted in different ways. Some use it to mean "you should do this because it makes you healthier" and others use it to mean "it isn;t harmful"
The Italian proverbial version of "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger" is "what doesn't kill you makes you fat" which, in the days of poverty and undernourishment that in Italy lasted till the 60s, was actually a good thing! It meant healthy!
post #11 of 14
5/1/10 at 3:38am
- DC Sunshine
- Other
- offline
- Joined 2/2007
- Location: Adelaide, South Australia
- Posts: 2,718
- Select All Posts By This User
I agree with guru - so avoid any high heat cooking with olive oil. It degrades the oil and turns it into a much unhealthier product. Save your olive oil for using raw, or for cooking at low temp. I don't know about the costs where you are, but it is way too expensive here to use large amounts for shallow/ deep fryin, apart from the info above about smoke point.
post #12 of 14
5/1/10 at 10:00am
- Koukouvagia
-
- Cook At Home
- offline
- Joined 4/2008
- Location: New York, NY
- Posts: 2,757
- Select All Posts By This User
I use olive oil for everything, even baking cakes sometimes. The only time I use a different oil is for deep frying. For that I use peanut oil.... but I throw in a little olive oil in there too.
post #13 of 14
5/1/10 at 11:06am
- siduri
- At home cook
- offline
- Joined 8/2006
- Location: Rome, Italy
- Posts: 2,770
- Select All Posts By This User
Ha, i do that too now that I stopped using it straight, Koukovagia, i use peanut oil and add a little extra virgin, just because it seems right.
I do stop short at baking with it, or any oil for that matter, since i way prefer butter. But olive goes into everything else.
I knew an Italian who had lived in the states for a while who asked me "Why do Americans use Crisco all the time?"
I told her they like to cook with it because it has no taste.
She said "So why would you cook with something if it has no taste??!!"
Just a general question to anyone who knows. Isn;t there a difference in chemical breakdown when the oil is cold-pressed? Cold pressed oil is only filtered. Hot pressed oil is washed with chemicals to remove the debris, and the traces of chemicals, as i understood it, are what is unhealthy when heated - they change with heat and produce toxic substances. This is what i read somewhere. Any scientists here who can answer with some real scientific knowledge?"
Also, how about clarified butter, what is the smoke point of that - is that ever used for frying? Not intending to use it but am curious.
I do stop short at baking with it, or any oil for that matter, since i way prefer butter. But olive goes into everything else.
I knew an Italian who had lived in the states for a while who asked me "Why do Americans use Crisco all the time?"
I told her they like to cook with it because it has no taste.
She said "So why would you cook with something if it has no taste??!!"
Just a general question to anyone who knows. Isn;t there a difference in chemical breakdown when the oil is cold-pressed? Cold pressed oil is only filtered. Hot pressed oil is washed with chemicals to remove the debris, and the traces of chemicals, as i understood it, are what is unhealthy when heated - they change with heat and produce toxic substances. This is what i read somewhere. Any scientists here who can answer with some real scientific knowledge?"
Also, how about clarified butter, what is the smoke point of that - is that ever used for frying? Not intending to use it but am curious.
post #14 of 14
5/1/10 at 1:58pm
I thought you all could use this when deciding what to fry with. As you can see, you would be right on the edge using extra virgin olive for some deep fat frying.
The following table presents smoke points of various fats:
The following table presents smoke points of various fats:
Fat![]() |
Quality![]() |
Smoke Point![]() |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Almond oil | 420°F | 216°C | |
| Avocado oil | 520°F | 271°C | |
| Butter | 350°F | 177°C | |
| Canola oil | Expeller Press | 464°F | 240°C |
| Canola oil | High Oleic | 475°F | 246°C |
| Canola oil | Refined | 470°F | 240°C |
| Coconut oil | Unrefined | 350°F | 177°C |
| Coconut oil | Refined | 450°F | 232°C |
| Corn oil | Unrefined | 320°F | 160°C |
| Corn oil | Refined | 450°F | 232°C |
| Cottonseed oil | 420°F | 216°C | |
| Flax seed oil | Unrefined | 225°F | 107°C |
| Ghee (Indian Clarified Butter) | 485°F | 252°C | |
| Grapeseed oil | 420°F | 216°C | |
| Hazelnut oil | 430°F | 221°C | |
| Hemp oil | 330°F | 165°C | |
| Lard | 370°F | 182°C | |
| Macadamia oil | 413°F | 210°C | |
| Olive oil | Extra virgin | 375°F | 191°C |
| Olive oil | Virgin | 420°F | 216°C |
| Olive oil | Pomace | 460°F | 238°C |
| Olive oil | Extra light | 468°F | 242°C |
| Olive oil, high quality (low acidity) | Extra virgin | 405°F | 207°C |
| Palm oil | Difractionated | 455°F | 235°C[1] |
| Peanut oil | Unrefined | 320°F | 160°C |
| Peanut oil | Refined | 450°F | 232°C |
| Rice bran oil | 490°F | 254°C | |
| Safflower oil | Unrefined | 225°F | 107°C |
| Safflower oil | Semirefined | 320°F | 160°C |
| Safflower oil | Refined | 510°F | 266°C |
| Sesame oil | Unrefined | 350°F | 177°C |
| Sesame oil | Semirefined | 450°F | 232°C |
| Soybean oil | Unrefined | 320°F | 160°C |
| Soybean oil | Semirefined | 350°F | 177°C |
| Soybean oil | Refined | 450°F | 232°C |
| Sunflower oil | Unrefined | 225°F | 107°C |
| Sunflower oil | Semirefined | 450°F | 232°C |
| Sunflower oil, high oleic | Unrefined | 320°F | 160°C |
| Sunflower oil | Refined | 450°F | 232°C |
| Tea seed oil | 485°F | 252°C | |
| Vegetable shortening | 360°F | 182°C | |
| Walnut oil | Unrefined | 320°F | 160°C |
| Walnut oil | Semirefined | 400°F | 204°C |
[edit]
Return Home
Back to Forum: Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion
- Cooking with Olive Oil Healthy?
ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food and Cooking Forums › Food & Cooking Questions and Discussion › Cooking with Olive Oil Healthy?
Currently, there are 245 Active Users
(15 Members and 230 Guests)
Recent Discussions
- › Update from a 19 year old. 6 minutes ago
- › Deconstructed Clam Chowder 8 minutes ago
- › Chinese cleavers vs. Japanese cleavers 8 minutes ago
- › How long does Christmas pudding last? 16 minutes ago
- › wedding cake disasters 17 minutes ago
- › Worst things about being a Chef 31 minutes ago
- › woof woof.... 49 minutes ago
- › A "life" question, I guess 51 minutes ago
- › The Boardsmith boards 53 minutes ago
- › Opening a B&B 1 hour, 18 minutes ago
View: New Posts | All Discussions
Recent Reviews
- › Le Creuset Enameled Cast-Iron 5-1/2-Quart Round French Oven, Red by RBandu
- › Tasting India by Waynus
- › Shun Premier Chef's Knife, 8-Inch by RBandu
- › Ken Onion 10" Chef's Knife by RBandu
- › Breville BCG800XL Smart Grinder by DuckFat
- › Guy Fieri Food: Cookin' It, Livin' It, Lovin' It by heath67013
- › T-fal Ultimate Enamel 10-1/4-Inch Saute Pan, Black by kshertzer
- › Tojiro-DP Chef's Knife 9.4" (24cm) by pjheard
- › Food and Friends: Recipes and Memories from Simca's Cuisine by JustPJ
- › Victorinox 8-Inch Chef's Knife, Rosewood Handle by RoflRocket
View: More Reviews
New Articles
- › How To Make Sorbet by Jim
- › why a chef you ask? by ChefGemneye
- › How To Make a Really Good Loaf of Whole... by JackBlack
- › Introduction To The Anti Griddle by m brown
- › Meals from the Masters by Jim
- › Nantua sauce by petalsandcoco
- › Coral sauce by petalsandcoco
- › Champagne and orange sauce by petalsandcoco
- › Paloise sauce by petalsandcoco
- › Creme Fleurette sauce by petalsandcoco
View: New Articles | All Articles
Home | Reviews | Forums | Articles | Galleries | My Profile
About ChefTalk.com | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 ChefTalk.com Inc. is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map
About ChefTalk.com | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 ChefTalk.com Inc. is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map








