My favorite is Mauviel copper/stainless cookware, I've got 6 saucepans, 11 3/4" skillet and 8" crepe pan. I use an electric range and these have worked out wonderfully for me; I started with my first one about 6-7 years ago and slowly acquired more. I've also used All Clad MC2 and had a whole set of Cuisinart stainless but wasn't that excited about either.
But recently I've been wanting a large saute pan, my only copper one is 1.9qt and I still have a stainless Cuisinart 3.5 qt and don't care for it much to the point where I'll use my large skillet instead if I can. But the Mauviel is sooo expensive for the saute pans, the 5 qt especially so I haven't taken the plunge.
At Costco the other day I took a chance and bought a Traqmontina 5qt deep saute pan for only $29.95 and it's amazing, stainless, it cooks completely evenly on my larger electric burner, even with so much of the pan hanging beyond the edge. I've been testing it with pancakes and eggs just to see how evenly it cooks and it's absolutely amazing. I did find it takes about 5 minutes to preheat the pan at medium heat compared to about 3 1/2 minutes with my copper skillet but wow it is worth it.
That Cooks Illustrated magazine had rated the Tranmontina 8qt stock pot almost up there with the All Clad at a quarter of the cost to I took a second look at this saute pan when I saw it at the store.
Would I still use it if I also had a copper one of the same size, I might say yes, because when they get this big, they get really heavy. I'm still pining for the Mauviel 3.5qt saute though, I just can't help it, they're wonderful products.
I think a lot of workling with anything is how well you know it, how much you use it and understand your conditions. I have many, many friends who are far better cooks than I and each has a 12" cast iron skillet on their stovetop all the time; they cook almost everything in it that is appropriate and will use no other skillet or saute pan. To the person they will all brag about these pans, some of which they've inherited from their moms and more than 30 years old...and so well seasoned to rival even the best non-stick pans out there.
I had a set of them at one point and gave them to a friend when I got into the copper...all he uses is the 12", a stock pot, and two saucepans on top of the stove. He is an excellent cook, as in fabulous so I really think there are a lot of pretty good choices out there...and yeah, I'll probably get another cast iron skillet myself and this time pay more attention.
Jannie...
Newbee:roll: