shroomgirl,
You asked,
ribeye is not a kosher part of a cow. Not sure what's up with that, anyone know?
If you're not "glatt kosher," you're good to go with the rib. When my family kept kosher, we got wonderful rib steaks from a kosher butcher. Trader Joe's is in the mainstream. At least as I understand it, it's only ultra-orthodox Jews (and by and large only in North America) who exclude the rib from the forequarter as treif.
Just speculating as to what is very "Inside Baseball" -- and let me say that I'm neither that deeply into it or knowledgeable about it -- but rib as treif may be more of an American Lubavitscher thing, than a worldwide, orthodox phenemenon.
Be interesting to hear what Ed has to say about it. He's cranked out a lot of kosher meals.
BDL
Edited by boar_d_laze - 9/7/10 at 5:58pm