I'd be pleased if you would share it. I've not heard this story.
OK, Grace. But don't go blaming me. You did ask, after all:
It came to pass, in the old days, in a small village in the Pale of Settlement, that bubbi was preparing dinner. She dropped a slice of buttered bread and, lo! it landed butter side up.
Whoever heard of such a thing?
She quickly called her husband and asked if he could explain it. Which, of course, he couldn’t. So they went to see the rabbi.
“Rabbi,” they asked, “how could this be, that the bread landed butter side up?”
The rabbi stroked his beard, and cleared his throat, and said, “in the Talmud are the answers to everything. Come back in a few days and I’ll have your answer.
The rabbi researched the holy book, but could find no explanation. “We will have to travel to the next town, where there is a better scholar than I. He will have the answer.”
At no small expense the rabbi, and the man, and the woman traveled to the next town, where there lived a talmudic scholar of some replutation.
“How could it be,” the rabbi asked, “that such a thing occurs; that the bread landed butter side down.”
“Come back in a week, and I will have your answer,” he replied.
A week later, at no small expense, they returned to the town scholar. “In the holy books,” he intoned, “all answers can be found if you know where to look. But, alas, I have not found the answer. We will have to travel to the big city, where there is a scholar of great renown. Surely he will know.”
So, the town scholar, and the rabbi, and the man, and the woman traveled to the city to consult with the scholar of great renown.
“In the holy books,” he intoned, “all answers can be found. Come back in a month and I will have the answer for you.”
A month later, the town scholar, and the rabbi, and the man, and the woman, at great expense, returned to the city.
“In the holy works,” repeated the city scholar, “all anwers can be found. And so it is in this case. I have diligently searched the Talmud and the Gomorrah, and the commentaries of all the great Rabbis. And I have uncovered the answer.”
The town scholar, and the rabbi, and the man, and the woman leaned forward, each anxious for the great revelation.
“After great and careful study,” said the city scholar of great renown, “it is quite apparent.” Turning towards the women, he said, “you obviously buttered the bread on the wrong side.”