i was thinking of buying a takeda chef knife, is it worth it?
- categoryChefs Knivestagged by System, 2/22/11
Related Forum Threads
- First Knife (I bet you guys are tired of this thread) Last post on 5/14/14 at 3:38pm in Cooking Knife Reviews
- Need help on finding the perfect knife set for me. Last post on 2/9/16 at 11:26am in Cooking Knife Reviews
- First Knife set advice Last post on 4/12/14 at 7:28am in Cooking Knife Reviews
- Which Chef Knife and Why? Last post on 3/30/14 at 8:26am in Cooking Knife Reviews
- In Japan For Holiday Looking For Some Knife Recommendations Last post on 3/22/14 at 11:32pm in Cooking Knife Reviews
How To Sharpen A Chefs Knife
Last edited: 1/7/12
- SantokuLast edited: 8/25/10
- Japanese Knives 101Last edited: 5/7/13
- Chef Knives How To Really Use ThemLast edited: 2/16/10
- How To Use A Chef Knife Part IILast edited: 8/31/13
So far im loving this school this is just my first semester so i can't judge to much but coming from my last school henry ford community college schoolcraft community college is so much better the...
The Chefs at The Chef's Academy in Indianapolis, In. Were amazing and knowledgeable. They showed interest with your creativity and looked forward to beating you with their hats when you did some...
I picked up one of these on sale with the intention of storing until Christmas. But that's a ways off, and I needed to verify it worked in case I needed to return it with in the warranty...
I've been looking for recipes and ideas I can ship off with my daughter to college and this book had a good variant idea on the one-pot meal. But the writing is chatty and cutesy. This doesn't...
I have to say it never occurred to me that such a unit would exist until I was working at one of my companies events and they had a catered breakfast in which the caterers would cook omelets to...
takedapost #1 of 122/21/11 at 4:29amThread Starter
ChefTalk.com Top Pickspost #2 of 122/22/11 at 2:19am
That's like asking if a Corvette is worth it. Or a pair of Reeboks. Or Philly Cream Cheese vs store brand. The short answer is yes- if you need a Takeda. They're great knives- thin, light and sharp. Of course, very reactive. And sometimes not ground as well as you'd like. Short of any qualifiers I'm just guessing if it will suit you. But I guess if you're asking if it's competitive performance-wise with other knives in the same price range, and saying for the sake of argument that you're competent to maintain it, the Takeda will serve you well. Again, assuming you know how to use it.
Crap...hoped to get thru this without using a derivative of "ass-u-me"...."Excellence is an art won by training and habituation. We do not act rightly because we have virtue or excellence, but we rather have those because we have acted rightly. We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act but a habit." - Aristotle"Excellence is an art won by training and habituation. We do not act rightly because we have virtue or excellence, but we rather have those because we have acted rightly. We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act but a habit." - Aristotlepost #3 of 122/22/11 at 4:25amThread Starter
phaedrus, my knife skills are very goo so i think i could handle it.i bought my frist shun last year and fell in love with the edge and have sence bought 9 more my favorite is the 10 inch elite with powdered steel and the bought the edge pro apex 5 to keep them sharp. but latly i been feeling that i want to upgrade and takeda seemed like a nice choice. p.s. if a knife is harder on the rockwell scale dos that mean it is better? i mean the twin cermax is a 66 but i do not want to go back to a german style bladepost #4 of 122/22/11 at 9:17am
Your question begs a lot of others. "Worth it" is a very soft concept, and your skill level is only part of the equation. In fact, your skill level as a sharpener is just as much if not more important. Also, you're unduly restricting the universe of good knives by limiting it to Takeda -- which is not only one manufacturer among many but represents a particular type of knife (san-mai aka three-layer) -- which may or may not be the best choice for you.
These remarks aren't meant as criticism of your choices in any way, but to expand your horizons a little before we get down to the business and pleasure of looking for that go-to gyuto you obviously want. You certainly don't have to answer to anyone on this board about your choice of knives. So, nor do they stand in the way of the basic principle: If you want it, and can afford it, why not?
BDLpost #5 of 122/22/11 at 2:16pm
I think it restricts it even more, BDL. Sounds like he's maybe drawn not just to san-mai but the Kourichi finish. Off the top of head, the most typical examples are Moritaka, Takeda and Carter. And to the OP, understand I'm not trying to be critical...it's just an extremely open ended question. Even if I knew you personally and worked next to you on the line it would be hard for me to surmise if a Takeda is worth it to you. Certainly it's a fine knife, though. If you like the "rustic" finish and the Wa style of handle it's a fine example of the breed.
BDL is spot on about sharpening. Since it's carbon it will require a bit more care. Aogami super will get very, very sharp but edge retention is a tad behind that of many tool and stainless steels. Plus, sitting unused you can lose a bit of your edge to corrosion. This isn't a deal breaker for me- I keep one AS knife in my work kit and I simply rotate thru them all. I'll then sharpen maybe half my knives on week, the rest the next."Excellence is an art won by training and habituation. We do not act rightly because we have virtue or excellence, but we rather have those because we have acted rightly. We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act but a habit." - Aristotlepost #6 of 122/23/11 at 8:39am
Maybe the real question here is whether the Takeda is worth the extra money compared to the Moritaka -- they're very, very similar but the Moritaka costs less.
I'm not a fan of san-mai knives at all, don't care for the very flat profile from either maker, and on top of that don't know enough about either to offer an opinion on what appears to be a very fine distinction. Phaedrus knows more, but one man's opinion is hardly a consensus.
Why not join Fred's Cutlery Forum and ask around there? I think you'll find a few people who have owned both knives.
BDLpost #7 of 122/23/11 at 12:22pm
Well, I can't say a lot about the Takedas based on first hand experience. But for my coin I'd buy the Moritaka- that's one I have used and enjoyed. The few guys I know that have extensively used both tend to concur that the Moritaka is about as good for less money.
Personally I like a very flat profile on a gyuto, the flatter the better. In fact, I'm really thinking about getting a Moritaka Kiritsuke which is flat as a board. Profile is one of the reasons I love my Akifusa so much. I wish CarboNext suji was that flat.post #8 of 122/23/11 at 6:57pm
Hi Spike - sorry to hi-jack your thread...
But... Phaedrus, can you expand on that statement a little for me, particularly re: AS? I'm trying to learn about steels, and which ones have which properties - carbon and stainless. As I currently understand it, white steel will take the sharpest edge, but is more suspect to corrosion and will not retain it's edge as long. Blue steel may not be able to get as sharp as white, but is more corrosion resistant and will hold it's edge longer. I still don't quite understand the nuances between white #1 & #2, or blue #1, #2 and super. All I know is that blue seems to be more expensive than white, and blue #1 seems to be the most expensive.
I've got a Moritaka 270 kiritsuke and I love it. The more I use it, the more I get into it. I can certainly see why BDL and others don't like san-mai and/or kurouchi, but for me the knife gets sharp, stays sharp, works well for me, and I like the feel of it. I just ordered a Moritaka 150 petty since I like their knives so much! I think they are a great value for blue super steel. Still not sure where I want to go long term - carbon vs ss. I'm trying to get a handle on which ss is "the best" and how that compares w/ blue & white re sharpness & edge retention.
Quote:post #9 of 122/23/11 at 7:27pmThread Starter
thanks guys for all the info, i have been cooking for over twenty years now and have always been proud of my knife skills but now that i have found japanese knifes i just can not get enough i just want to buy the right knife in the 300 to 400 hundred range thanks again guys and i really listen to all the info you are givingpost #10 of 122/23/11 at 7:52pmThread Starterpost #11 of 122/25/11 at 10:14am
"Rockwell 'C' Hardness" can be very tricky as a knife metric. Of the three types of measured hardnesses (impact, indentation and scratch), it measures indentation which is the only one not directly applicable. All hardness measures are incredibly difficult to do accurately. And finally, you're on to something with the comparison to ceramics. Very hard knives tend to be chippy and difficult to maintain.
BDLpost #12 of 122/28/11 at 8:05pm
Hardness also impacts the difficulty of sharpening. Knives in the mid 60s are notoriously hard to sharpen from dull. It becomes imperative that you maintain the edge frequently rather than let it dull down.
ChefTalk.com Top Picks
- › What did you have for dinner? 1 hour, 31 minutes ago
- › Please Help Me Understand Food Seasons 2 hours, 24 minutes ago
- › I missed it.. but love the words of Anthony Bourdain 2 hours, 43 minutes ago
- › Atkins and other High-Fat Diets... 3 hours, 52 minutes ago
- › If you had the chance to go to Spain and Italy what would you bring... 4 hours, 35 minutes ago
- › Question 2 specific types of curry, what are they. 4 hours, 37 minutes ago
- › September 2016 Cooking Challenge: Bread 4 hours, 45 minutes ago
- › Making chicken fettuccine Alfredo with broccoli for 150 people 7 hours, 4 minutes ago
- › Working the grill, any advice? 7 hours, 30 minutes ago
- › Looking for a decent chefs knife and 50 $ and sharpening tool? 7 hours, 33 minutes ago
- › Schoolcraft College Culinary Arts Program by chefpeaches
- › Chef Academy by TheCookSaigium
- › Anova WiFi Sous Vide Precision Cooker, Black by phatch
- › Sheet Pan Suppers: 120 Recipes for Simple, Surprising, Hands-Off... by phatch
- › Iwatani Gas Cassette Burner Stove by eastshores
- › Italian Chef Academy - Rome by tessy
- › Wine Bottle Cooler Stick - 3-in-1 Stainless Steel Wine Chiller... by majorc
- › Meat Thermometer - Instant Read LCD Screen Auto Shut-Off with Long... by majorc
- › Le Cordon Bleu USA by freshbaked
- › Professional Baking by Daniel Benitez