- categoryCookbookstagged by System, 3/14/11
Related Forum Threads
- Review Reader Poll Last post on 6/2/11 at 7:00am in Cookbook Reviews
- Looking for cookbook with recipes to turn daily humdrum meals into flavor rich dishes Last post on 3/18/11 at 1:12pm in Cookbook Reviews
- Stockpot Recommendations from New England Soup Factory Last post on 10/17/12 at 9:32am in Cooking Equipment Reviews
- Modernist Cuisine Last post on 5/2/13 at 4:57pm in Cookbook Reviews
- Searching for a certain book on bread slashing Last post on 2/20/11 at 6:28am in Cookbook Reviews
I recently had the joy of picking up "The German Kitchen" by Christopher and Catherine Knuth and I have to say that I was pleasantly surprised. The book's tag line is "Traditional Recipes,...
Instructions to the Cook Bernard Glassman & Rick Fields Reviewed by Jim Berman Guilty! I judged a book by its cover. I was in between titles, waiting for Ivan Ramen and the new Rene...
Ever since my first day of culinary school over 15 years ago I had thought of a product like this. A comfortable and ROOMY knife bag that can hold all of my knives, gadgets and my laptop. Being a...
For quite a while the neighborhood bakery seemed to be dying out, just like the neighborhood butcher and other individually-owned businesses. Along with this unfortunate trend was the loss of the...
It’s hard to imagine Julia Childs as anything other than a famous chef and author—her persona just seems to radiate Kitchen-chic. Yet, the story of Julia finding herself is richer than you would...
what is CookBook Reviews?
ChefTalk.com Top Picks
Cookbook Reviews is a forum where Cheftalk members can discuss cookbooks and other books related to culinary matters. Open a few of the threads and you'll see that discussions range across the spectrum, from discussing the pros and cons of a specific book, to searching for types of books.
This is different from formal reviews, which all members can also write, if they like. Just go through the process of finding the book page (almost all food-oriented books handled by Amazon have their own page), click where it says "write a review," and go to it. If you look at the right-hand column on this page you'll see a couple of member-written reviews.
Different, too, are the featured reviews written by our staff of book reviewers. Currently there are about a dozen of them, and we're always looking for additional talent. These are the reviews you see highlighted in the carousel on top of the home page.
I have the great priviledge of being the reviews editor. If you like to join us, contact me directly (Brook@cheftalk.com) and I'll send you the details.
I am a professional cookbook/food book reviewer and I review some eight a month for various review sites.
. We only review brand new books, often before they hit the market. Unfortunately, reviews are brief, limited to 200 words but that gives you a pretty good idea whether a book is worth investing on and crowding your already full cookbook shelf.
Edited to remove spam.
Other than bragging about your job, Gerdosh, I fail to see how your post has any relevance to the OPs question.
Self-promotion is one thing. But it should at least be germane to the discussion at hand. Or do you think the dozen-odd folks who write full reviews for Cheftalk should use this space to promote themselves too?
BTW, the link you provided doesn't work.
It's a place where the members ask for suggestions for particular styles of cookbooks, or some members post up reviews of cookbooks they own or borrowed.
Occasionally, e-book spammers come along to spam the forum or others will copy and paste blurbs about their books/blogs/websites. These are usually violations of the user agreement and get deleted and the abusing member gets banned.
Actually I have no interest promoting myself (I have nothing to promote). I posted three links in my reply where cookbooks are reviewed (among many other book genres) for general interest but, sadly, they were deleted as spam. So my posting became irrelevant.
Just my thoughts, take it with a grain of salt.
I'm a little uncomfortable with this thread.
There was editing.
There was talk of banishm .
There were accusations.
I personally wish someone would close this thread. So it could started over.
There is really no reason for Dr. Erdosh to self promote here at ChefTalk. He is very accomplished.
I personally own a few of books and I really enjoy them. Tried and True recipes is worth owning.
His catering books (sorry I can't remember the title) are very informative especially for someone going into business.
You will find his books about African American kitchens is in our public school libraries.
There was no intention to promote here, only inform.
I may be way off base, If I have this poster totally confused with someone else, please delete. or let me know
Like I said, take it with a grain of salt.
To be honest, I recognized the name a couple of months ago and could'nt place it.
I did not see what was deleted. I don't really care.
I was a little taken back while reading. I had the opportinity to re-review the guideline last
week. It mentions there can be no selling/promoting products. I understood it as not trying to generate business or income.
I did not recall it saying that anything about posting references to blogs and websites. I see this done all the time in the forums.
I actually think it approves this in the agreement.
I also did not recall anything about self promotion. That's also abundant in the forums.
I mean no harm. The agreement says I am free to disagree. So here I am
We've allowed it once a member has shown they're a committed contributing member. Links like that will get deleted from a newcomer's posts until then, Generally between 10-20 substantive posts. Spammers don't have that patience. Usually just a few posts with links and they're gone.
I'm cool with everything. I don't know what was deleted. I don't know if there was a breach of the agreement or spam.
I got involved where I should'nt have. I will absolutely leave it alone after this post.
I've actually held my toungue. The only guideline or rule that I viewed as broken was the
one referencing being rude. It would make me unhappy to see any member go away for something t.
speaking in general
What's holding you up, BurgerDude? Surely you've read a cookbook that you found particularly good or bad? Or one that tripped your trigger for some reason.
Wow! I didn't mean to create such an uproar. But honestly, I meant strictly to inform giving three links to three book review magazine that are given away FREE. So really, there is nothing to promote.
First off, BurgerDude, you don't have to be a Chef to have an opinion of cookbook, or to raise a discussion of them. Our membership runs the gamut, from at-home tyros to top rated professionals. So don't let the idea that your "just" a home cook deter you.
Other than that, just start working your way through the various threads on this forum. Lots and lots of reviews, summaries, and opinions.
For more formal reviews, check out the carousel on the home page, and the listings of recent activity. Numerous book reviews appear there, including those from our staff of reviewers.
In short, if you're looking for discussions about cookbooks, there is no lack of them.
- what is CookBook Reviews?
- › Who makes jam or jelly? 14 minutes ago
- › This thread may add a few Lbs! 18 minutes ago
- › NEW 26 minutes ago
- › NYC Hotel Unions 41 minutes ago
- › too much glamour to the exec and not enough respect for guys on the... 44 minutes ago
- › Homemade Beef Sausage 1 hour, 10 minutes ago
- › What are your favorite simple sandwich recipes? 1 hour, 21 minutes ago
- › CIA vs paul smith 1 hour, 28 minutes ago
- › Copper Cleaning 1 hour, 48 minutes ago
- › Cayenne pepper from Kroger compared with Penzeys 1 hour, 55 minutes ago
- › The German Kitchen: Traditional Recipes, Regional Favorites by Pete
- › Instructions to the Cook: A Zen Master's Lessons in Living a... by Jim Berman
- › ChefPak by Pepperedfig
- › The Brown Betty Cookbook by prtybrd
- › Dearie: The Remarkable Life of Julia Child by BenRias
- › The Book Of Yogurt by Pete
- › Meat A Benign Extravagance by Fairlie, Simon [Chelsea Green,2010]... by hwood
- › Sun Bread and Sticky Toffee: Date Desserts from Everywhere by Cami
- › The Professional Bakeshop by Jim Berman
- › Shun Classic 6-1/2-Inch Stainless-Steel Nakiri Knife by Mark Hernen
- › A November Sunday in Torremolinos by ChrisBelgium
- › Orange Sherbet by Jim Berman
- › Malaga, a walk along tapa bars by ChrisBelgium
- › The First Timer's Guide to Roasting a... by Pete
- › A Brining We Shall Do by kaneohegirlinaz
- › Espresso + Gelato: The first in a series on... by Jim Berman
- › My Evening With Durangojo by kaneohegirlinaz
- › Polenta's Potential Predicated by ChefMannyDLM
- › Making Sauerkraut by Pete
- › Florida Lobster - Out of the kitchen and into... by eastshores