or Connect
ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food & Equipment Reviews › Cooking Knife Reviews › Searching for a honesuki/petty 150mm 50/50 bevel
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Searching for a honesuki/petty 150mm 50/50 bevel

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 
Hello everyone,

When i finish culinary scholl i bought a set of global knifes with my savings from my part times at restaurants.

Since the beggining i didn't like of the flexibility and profile of my boning knive (g21) so i always use my chef knife (G2) for all the boning/meat.

Meanwhile i practice my knife skills and tried some different knifes from collegues as i was working at diferent jobs and i really like the feeling of some honesukis.

I am lefty, line cook and i am searching for a double edge, sharp and easy to maintain boning knife - just for meat because i like to work with my deba and a flexible knife on fish.

My sharpening skills are average and i want to spend (at the maximum) 200 dollars.

I have seen a Al Mar honesuki ultra chef that looks nice, do you know that knife?

Thank you for all your opinions and advices.

Joel Vieira
post #2 of 20
Two approaches are possible with deboning: a very thin, symmetric French désosseur, or a a very asymmetric, thick, stiff, Japanese garasuki or hankotsu. Would you like the Japanese way, have a look at Masahiro's Virgin Carbon line. A lefty version will cost you some 25% more than the standard version.
The French use it to butcher an entire cow, and prefer their soft steel for easy steeling and repairing damages. The Japanese use much harder steel types, and will prefer thicker blades to limit damage.
post #3 of 20

You might want to take a look at this thread from the past in ChefTalk - it features a query FROM (and not directed to) BDL.




Daniel from Mad Cow Cutlery gives about the best overview of butcher cutlery I have ever read.  The entire thread is an eye opener - and could stretch your perceptions of what can be used.


Note that what's being described is strictly for commercial and industrial use - which means that it's not just what works on the shop floor, but what's economical.


As for the Al Mar Ultra-Chef honesuki, I have not handled either one of the two models (wood handle or all-metal).  But I did buy as an impulse item a 210mm Al Mar Ultra-Chef Damascus gyuto, with Cocobolo handle scales.  I was not particularly impressed by the fit & finish, but I figured I needed at least one "Drawer Queen" - and I bought it at auction on eBay for about 40% of list price.


Personally, I have a MAC honesuki - strictly right-handed (as I am) and asymetrically single bevel.  In my case, I was looking at the low end of the market and narrowed my choice to the Tojiro DP, the MAC and the Richmond Artifex.  I chose the MAC over the Tojiro DP because the MAC uses a moly steel which is probably tougher when the (inevitable) impact of the blade edge hits bone - and I did not want to have that edge in VG-10 steel.  I also chose the MAC over the Artifex because the MAC has a bolster and the Artifex does not - and I did not want the handle to have any forward crevices to trap grease or residues.  And finally, I bought the MAC by winning an eBay auction and saving about 40% over the general MAC price of $115 (as most of my friends and family would tell you, I am frugal, if not cheap)..


Hopefully, the above thread and my ramblings will give you some precise info.



Galley Swiller

post #4 of 20
Thread Starter 
Thank you both for your opinions and knowledge.

I will study the thread. wink.gif

Joel Vieira
post #5 of 20

I have some recommendations for you:

1 and 2) either Konosuke HD2 or the HH. The HH line lives in the shadow of the HD, but this is an amazing alloy with excelent heat treatment, which combined with light weight results in amazing performance. They are also thinner than other honesukis.

3) kikuichi elite carbon;

and 4) don´t tell anyone I am telling you that, but Shun BLUE steel.


They are all excelent and in the $150 - $200 range.

French knives are awesome too, unfortunatelly I do not have much experience to recommend you any, but both BDL and Benuser can.


Good luck!

post #6 of 20
Thread Starter 
Masahiro's Virgin carbon line look's a good knife but i am not used to single bevel.

Also there is not a lot of information about the steel. It is a swedish stainless steel right?

It's easy to adapt to single bevel: use and sharpenig are totally differents right?

I also would like to use the honesuki for small tasks. A idea that i have (maybe i am tottally wrong) is that a double bevel is more "all around". Am i wrong?

Galley Swiller:
Thank you for showing me the thread, i have read it and learned a lot from it.

I have read a lot of good things about the konosuke's but unfortunelly i only have find righ hand versions (i am lefty).

The kikuichi elite carbon looks a good knife, do you know the knife? Double bevel? What about the handle?

Thank you all!
Edited by jcnvieira - 10/18/13 at 1:10pm
post #7 of 20
About the Masahiro: it's virgin carbon, so carbon steel, not stainless. Single or double bevel: there is some misunderstanding here. Even if they are strongly asymmetric, or even advertised as single bevel, it's strictly speaking no single bevel where the back face is concave. Here the back face is flat with a very small bevel. Sharpening is very easy: you basically sharpen only the kanji side, and deburr the other one. Would you mean to redress the proportions somewhat: start by sharpening the back face for once.
post #8 of 20
Thread Starter 

Thank you for the tips.
Yes, you are totally right: the Masahirk is made of carbon steel so is not a valid option to me.

I have a question: do any one know if Chef Knives to Go or Japanese Imports modify a knife from 70/30 bevel to 50/50 bevel?

Yesterday I send an email to Mark from Chef Knives to go about that.

I am reading a lot and asking for advices and ideas. Until now i liked those two knifes:

- Konosuke HH Honesuki 150mm
- Gehnssin Ginga Wa Honesuki 150mm (they have Yo option that i supose it is 50/50 bevel but i am going to call to confirm).

Can you give me your opinions?

Have a nice weekend.

Joel Vieira
post #9 of 20
Dear Joel,
A neutral 50/50 honesuki is a bad solution, I think. We may discuss the marginal benefits of asymmetry with other knives, but with a honesuki, which is quite thick, you want the edge to be as close as possible to the bone.
That's why I suggested a left handed version. It's not so much about the edge. The entire blade is strongly asymmetric, the face being very convexed, and the back deadly flat.
As far as I know the Masahiro Carbons are the only to have their entire series fully adapted to left-handed. Misono produces left-handed honesukis as well on special order. Check with JCK,
japanesechefsknife.com, and ask Mr Koki Iwahara for advice, koki@kencrest.us
Enjoy your weekend and have a good week.
post #10 of 20

neither of those is left handed friendly... its not just the bevel that is right handed, but the construction and geometry of the knife.  Therefore, "converting" it is not really a good idea, as it would still be  a right handed knife, but with a left handed bevel.  Try to go for something really 50/50 if you can... i know i've got at least one thing around like that.

post #11 of 20
Thread Starter 

Thank you for your advices. Hafe a good


Thanks for your advice. I had no idea if it was too radical to transform a knife to double bevel but you explain and justify why it shouln't be done.

What is your advice?

Does a 150mm petty fit better the use that i want? (Boning, fruit and a little bit of herbs)
post #12 of 20

i would say either get a 50/50 one, a real left handed one, or choose a 150mm petty that is on the tough/durable side of things.  The petty is probably most versatile, but you will need to be a bit more careful.

post #13 of 20
A good stainless petty which is not overly thin and fragile would be the Hiromoto G3. A great steel, easy sharpening.
post #14 of 20
Thread Starter 
Thank you for the tips. What 150mm petty 50/50 bevelyou would advice to me?

Thank you. Any more sugestion? I would like a asian handle but it seems impossible to find one in 50/50 bevel knife.
post #15 of 20
With a thin petty these proportions aren't that critical. Edge asymmetry can be sharpened out in one simple session.
post #16 of 20
Thread Starter 
Thank you Benuser.

Does anyone knows about a 50/50 bevel 150mm petty stainless steel under $200?
post #17 of 20

as i also happen to be a retailer, i'm not so comfortable making recommendations of my products on here... if you would like to speak in more depth, you're always welcome to e-mail or PM me though.

post #18 of 20
Thread Starter 
Thank you all for your help. I decided for a Konosuke HH 150mm Petty.

All the best,

Joel Vieira
post #19 of 20
Thread Starter 
Unfortunelly the konosuke 150mm was sould out so i am back to find "the knife". Hehe
post #20 of 20



For a decent working Boner.

I use a meatworks $27 special  6in narrow. Curved stiff blade.


Professionals use them ALL day. very day on piece work rates. They KNOW what's best for that job.

Most of my others are Wusthof.

But I can't find a decent Boner that works in any of the fancy knives...

These do.



Just a thort.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Cooking Knife Reviews
ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food & Equipment Reviews › Cooking Knife Reviews › Searching for a honesuki/petty 150mm 50/50 bevel