or Connect
ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food & Equipment Reviews › Cooking Knife Reviews › Help Deciding on Knives - Shun vs Kagayaki
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Help Deciding on Knives - Shun vs Kagayaki

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 

Hey! So I have been looking into buying a knife and after reading a lot of different forums, I saw the two knives linked below. I've heard great things about the steel that Shun uses, but the Kagayaki knives also seem to be very high quality. Does anyone have experience with these two knives that could help me narrow down the decision? Thanks in advance!

 

Shun Classic Asian Chef's Knife - 7" gyuto

http://www.williams-sonoma.com/products/shun-classic-asian-chefs-knife/?pkey=cknives-shun&cm_src=knives-shun||NoFacet-_-NoFacet-_--_-

 

Kagayaki VG-10 - 9.4" gyuto

http://www.japanesechefsknife.com/KAGAYAKIVG-10.html

post #2 of 9
Shun has given a bad reputation to VG-10 by performing a poor Heat Treatment and it's a shame.
Kagayaki does its HT very well amongst everything else and you should expect an outstanding knife.
post #3 of 9

The only good Shun Ive used so far is the honesuki blue. The VG10 version is a shame. Go Kagayaki or even cheaper , but still better than Shun, tojiro DP.

another thing... considering gyutos, size does matter. If you are buying it for home, go with a 240mm (9.4"), if for professional use go with a 270mm (10.6").

 

Are you only considering VG10? there are other good alloys, clad or not, inox or carbon, with better performance in the same price range.

 

Best regards,

Daniel.

post #4 of 9
Thread Starter 

Thanks for the input Benuser and dhmcardoso!

 

To be honest, those were just some knives that I found by searching. I haven't done much research into alloys - most of what I was looking at was the blade style (French, German, etc.). I'm definitely open to any recommendations and suggestions!

post #5 of 9
You're welcome, Jazzman. Would you be interested in carbon steel as well, or semi-stainless, or a carbon core with a stainless clad? And how do you sharpen? Are you right- or left-handed?
post #6 of 9
You are welcome.
Just adding to Benuser questions. Do you already have the wetstones? If you don't you will need it. So what is your total budget?
Another important tool is The cutting board. Do you have a wood end or Edge grain board?
post #7 of 9

Hi,

 

""Another important tool is The cutting board. Do you have a wood end or Edge grain board?""

 

 

 

What is the difference.

If steel alloys that sensitive. It can't be a good thing?

 

Both my Wusthof and Mundial (8 in\6 in) will cut thick skin tomatoes with their own weight. Just push\pull the handles.

So I keep them fairly sharp (around 18\20deg angle on cutting edge) and you can bang them around as much as you like virtually.

 

Just wondering. as I'm thinking of buying a Tojiro  7in Santoku to try? and my 8in Wusthof is in process of updating for a 240.

 

 

How sensitive are these VG10 blades.

I've bought a Tojiro 6in Utility as a toe in water, so to speak.

 

I've had mainly Wusthof and a coupla Mundial for near 50 yrs.

And understood those Tojiro were a good starter tool in my situation.

At 72 I won't be buying too many more methink's.    Chuckle.

post #8 of 9
Thread Starter 

To answer all of the questions I can, I would eventually look into carbon steel, but I know those are more difficult to maintain so I would probably want to start with semi-stainless for now.  I am right handed. I don't have whetstones and don't have much experience sharpening (I would go to a pro until I learn on a  cheaper blade). I have an edge board, but I will probably get an end board soon. And since I am mostly researching, I don't want to limit myself too much by budget. I know that good whetstones are normally around $100 and the knives I was looking at range from ~$100-150. 

post #9 of 9
The reason I asked about the steel preference is that stainless are much harder to sharpen than carbons. Maintenance of carbons is not hard but does require a little discipline.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Cooking Knife Reviews
ChefTalk.com › ChefTalk Cooking Forums › Food & Equipment Reviews › Cooking Knife Reviews › Help Deciding on Knives - Shun vs Kagayaki