I use waterstones but one of my guys and friend thinks they are too messy. I offered him both my 8k and 16k shapton glass stones for 100.00 which is a beck of a deal for two stones. He is thinking of buying the tojiro pull through sharpened. I personally don't know much about it, but have used that type of sharpener in the past and was no good for my knives. What say you guys? Have you used it and how well did it work? He is using Tojiro do knives.
Anyone try the Tojiro sharpener?
ChefTalk.com Top Picks
Probably much like the Minosharp, but you can get that as a 3-stage. Here are the KKF replies
Even though the Tojiro is a roll sharpener, show him this video, things get pertinent at 2:30 through:
As Millions had pointed out, "That is exactly the cry a knife makes in those sharpeners."
Main point actually, there is nothing messy about a shapton stone, it's not like they're a mud-binder.
What I would use is irrelavent, but I believe the typical user here would be happy with the 1.5K. 2 stones maybe a 400 and 2K. I don't think the pull thru would give a better finish than 2K. If the individual didn't care about thinning and actually wanted a more refined edge, then 1K and 6K.
Leaning toward pull thru as he was, I especially don't think the 8k and 16k is the best setup for him.