@chefwriter ,
You're right. There was a little more info given. Both these Chefs were from restaurants right in this little local foodi area. They all use basically the same vendors. They just use the products in their own eclectic ways. They should know what they can get and the minimums and maximums. She named a dish. They both had time to write down a purchase list. One did manually and the other in his head. My Chef buddy didn't really care about plate presentation or how the dish was prepared . She was trying to see if the Chef was creative with the unused product. You know, you can't buy 1 pork chop. or 1 stalk of broccoli. This is where they stumbled. The Chef who wrote down his list did better, but nothing interesting. His labor was accurate and knew his prices and has a GM on site.
The other Chef was off a bit on his labor but way off on his costs and his restaurant was part of a managing group with no one on the property.
The FOH and BOH was just a curiosity question for her own information. All three of the places are approx. the same amount of seats and dinner only. She was just trying to see where she stood
in her Labor costs.
All three of these places are what I call ( New Style). Mostly reductions, no stocks, really no on site preparation like dry age or pickling etc. and some package opening. Average entree 28++
You would have breezed through it. She is a good Chef, born and raised in a restaurant in Germany. Never once balked when I raise a price on something because of butter, eggs, milk. She just passed it on.