[mezzaluna]

I'm making key lime pie for dessert for dinner tomorrow evening. Can I make this the day before (i.e., more than "overnight")? Do I put plastic wrap on the surface of the pie to prevent skin forming or not worry about that?

Thanks in advance,

Mezzaluna

The recipe is from King Arthur Flour website:

Crust:

1 cup + 2 tablespoons very finely ground salted pretzel crumbs

3 tablespoons sugar

7 tablespoons butter, melted

Filling

4 large egg yolks

two 14-ounce cans sweetened condensed milk

3/4 cup Floribbean Key lime juice (I'm using Nellie and Joe's)

3 tablespoons Persian lime juice (juice of 1 medium lime), optional

zest of 1 lime (about 2 teaspoons), optional

Method:

1. Preheat the oven to 350F. Lightly grease a 9" pie pan with non-stick baking spray.
2. Crush the pretzels until very fine; processing in the food processor for about 30 seconds works well.
3. Add the sugar and melted butter, mixing to combine; you can do this right in the food processor. Press the mixture into the bottom and up the sides of the prepared pan.
4. Bake for 8 to 10 minutes; the crust won't change color much, but will firm up. Remove from the oven and make the filling.
5. Whisk together the egg yolks and condensed milk.
6. Add the lime juice (and zest if using). The mixture will thicken almost immediately.
7. Pour into the crust and smooth with a spatula.
8. Bake the pie for 28-32 minutes, until the filling is set, with a small spot in the middle still soft-looking. Cool for several hours (or overnight) before serving.
9. To serve, top with slightly sweetened whipped cream and a garnish of crumbled pretzels.

Yield: one 9" pie, 8 servings (or 4 if you're my husband! /img/vbsmilies/smilies/lol.gif It's one of his favorites.)

 

[phatch]

In my custard experiences, the biggest problem is weeping watery liquid. With the topping at service, I think you'll be OK a day ahead. There will probably be some crust degradation but not significant at that point. Day 2, the crust will likely be suffering some sogginess.

 

[panini]

Mezzaluna,

Hello old friend.

May I suggest that you refrigerate the pie for a short time to bring down temp and then overwrap the whole thing. That should take care of weeping. We also temper the yolks over heat as not to use the raw egg.

We use the pretzel for the crust and add salt, add a little Tequila and Triple Sec to mix. Margarita pie/img/vbsmilies/smilies/drinkbeer.gif

 

[mezzaluna]

Dear @Panini! Always wonderful to see you. /img/vbsmilies/smilies/smiles.gif

The pie will be baked; do the yolks still need tempering if they're being mixed with the condensed milk and the lime juice? If it were a true custard (which I'm not completely sure this is...?) I would certainly do so. With SO much sugar and the extra-dense protein in the condensed milk, would it still be necessary? King Arthur doesn't say so, but they've been known to make mistakes now and then. (although I'm wild about their gluten free recipes so far. /img/vbsmilies/smilies/rolleyes.gif)

 

[foodnfoto]

From a former Key West pastry chef-

For the classic KLP-we use graham cracker crumbs, but pretzels will be OK, if only a little Yankee-fied.

The ratio is 4 yolks to one 14 ounce can of sweetened condensed milk, to 1/3 cup of real key lime juice (Nellie & Joe's or Floribbean are both good)-all for a 9" shallow dish pie

Please, do not add spanish limes! And do not add lime zest, it just makes the custard bitter and ruins the creamy filling with little bitter flakes! 

Your baking time is a little long but if you are doing double the SCM and lime juice, you might need it.

Do NOT allow it to brown AT ALL! It should be a little puffed around the edges, but still jiggly in the middle when you pull it from the oven. 

Note-it always weeps a little once chilled, just blot it off before you top it with whipped cream.

HOWEVER!

The traditional topping is a huge mound of billowy baked meringue. This should be put on right after you remove the pie from the oven and when the custard is still hot. This will prevent the meringue from weeping and shrinking. 

When you remove the pie from the oven, bump the heat up to 450˚F while you prepare the meringue from your reserved egg whites. I use about 1 ounce of sugar per white. Warm the whites and sugar together until the sugar is dissolved, then beat on medium speed (not high) until stiff , not dry, peaks form. Pile the meringue onto the hot custard and spread with the back of a spoon to touch all the crust edges and form an even layer. Then press the spoon into the meringue and pull out quickly to form peaks!

Place in the 450˚ oven and bake until golden brown and the peaks are almost black. 

Cool to room temp, then chill thoroughly before serving. 

Yum

 

[chefedb]

Graham crumbs s the only traditional pie.   Pretzels??

 

[mezzaluna]

The ratio is 4 yolks to one 14 ounce can of sweetened condensed milk, to 1/3 cup of real key lime juice (Nellie & Joe's or Floribbean are both good)-all for a 9" shallow dish pie

Yeah, I thought there was an awful lot of milk for just four yolks. Your ratio is the same on as on the Nellie and Joe's bottle. The baking time seemed long to me too, but then I never set the timer for the full baking time when I'm doing a recipe for the first time. I always knock off 25% of the time, take a look and go from there. You can always add time. If I were serving this at my house instead of transporting it, I'd probably go with the meringue. I don't have a pie tote to accommodate the "pouf".

I don't have graham crackers, nor do I have a chance to buy any before I have to make this tomorrow morning, so the crust will be made with pretzel crumbs. I'm leaving out the lime zest, didn't intend to use it in the first place so we're on the same page there. /img/vbsmilies/smilies/biggrin.gif And I'll trust foodnfoto's experience for the ratios and ditch KAF's recipe for the filling, too. /img/vbsmilies/smilies/thumb.gif

While I do like Panini's idea to make it a little more "festive" with some tequila, I must omit alcohol for this meal. But boy, you gave me some great ideas for the next time around!

 

[phatch]

Does alcohol mess with the setting power of the eggs? 

And be sure to post the pie as an entry in the eggs challenge!

 

[durangojo]

Sure i'm too late in time for you making a key lime pie this go round but i have been making and serving this one for over 20 years at our restaurant...people(even floridians) say its the best, and i agree...it's the perfect balance of sweet and tart and simplicity...we dress it up a bit with a mango coulis, fresh whipped cream and a few blueberries, but it can stand alone all on its own.....the recipe is from Joe's Stone Crab House in Miami, which has been there since the early 1900's sonthe recipe is definitely tried and true..my endorsement is minor to the 100 years that Joe's have been making people smile with theirs.

http://joesstonecrab.com/recipes/keylime.html

Fyi....I make them two at a time, cool down, then freeze....they are easier to cut evenly for restaurant service when frozen and i like to serve them with a bit of a chill on them...never had a problem with the crust being soggy, but i use pre made graham cracker crusts which i brush with melted butter and bake for 8 minutes before filling.....perfect every time....i mean, every single time!

joey
Ps...lime zest is essential!

 

[foodnfoto]

Call me a stickler, call me OCD, call me a traditionalist-

It's not Key Lime Pie if you don't use key lime juice. 

Any why everyone has to put lime zest in it is beyond me. Yeaccchhh.

 

[chefedb]

I use stone crab formula to . Never had a problem serve  it atop of raspberry coulli, whipped cream and slice of candied lime.

 

[panini]

phatch

I haven't found that the alcohol doesn't effect that much. But after seconds, it pretty much doesn't matter/img/vbsmilies/smilies/wink.gif

 

[mezzaluna]

I made foodnfoto's recipe proportions with the pretzel crust. I didn't use booze because I seem to remember not to use alcohol for one of the people who will eat this, so I'm leaving it out for that reason and no other.

The filling set nicely at about 19 minutes. I let it cool completely on the counter, covered the plate (being careful to avoid touching the surface of the filling) and put it in the fridge by 9 AM. I have whipping cream but I also have five egg whites (I goofed up and threw away one of the egg yolks by accident). I just made a pie for the first time and will serve it at a dinner party, so why not go all out and try making the meringue too?

Am I going to have trouble if I make and bake the meringue on a cold pie? Or should I let the pie sit out of the fridge for a bit first? Failing that, should I skip it since I didn't make the meringue while the pie was still hot? My egg whites are at room temperature.

Questions, questions, but you all are the best ones to ask them of. Gotta love Chef Talk, where a home cook can get answers from patient pros. /img/vbsmilies/smilies/smile.gif

Mezz

Added later: I've checked lemon meringue pie recipes that have add meringue to a chilled pie or bringing the pie to room temperature before adding the meringue, and then baking anywhere from 20-30 minutes, depending on how much meringue there is.

Extra note: it's very humid today. Should I bother making meringue?

Thoughts?

 

[phatch]

Thanks, @panini just something I was wondering.

 

[foodnfoto]

You can still do the meringue Mezz, even after cooling the pie. Just make it as close to the time you plan to serve it as possible. 

One trick I learned from Shirley Corriher with meringue topped pies is to sprinkle a fine layer of fine dry breadcrumbs on the top of the cooled custard before topping it. This keeps the meringue from slipping around even if it does weep some due to the humidity and the cooled custard. 

If you worry about the humidity of the day, make the meringue by boiling the sugar to soft ball stage and then slowly beat it into partially whipped whites. Then beat until peaks form. 

Swiss meringue seems to hold up to humidity a little better in my experience. 

 

[mezzaluna]

@foodnfoto, your filling was delicious! Clearly, the recipe from KAF would have been far too milky and not citrusy enough. I wasn't at all wild about the pretzel crust, but it was okay. I ended up serving sweetened whipped cream (I had a can of it in the fridge) but also had some whipping cream, which I didn't sweeten and stabilized with a smidge of corn starch. It held up very well and I didn't have any pie to bring home.

@phatch I could kick myself: I forgot to take a picture for the egg challenge! But I'll post about it there anyway.

Thanks, everyone, for your help and advice.

 

[foodnfoto]

Oh so glad to know you liked it Mezz!

You know, classics are classics for good reason. Why mess with a good thing?

 

[panini]

foodnfoto,

I knew from your Bio not to get involved with the formula, you practically created it. LOL

Liquored up and laquered down,
She's got the biggest hair in town

Kind of reminds me of a margarita tart with merengue. Just curious if you've ever tried something like this?

I grabbed one from the bakery yesterday. I really like them but we don't use the merengue. We do use a drop of green food color.

 

[foodnfoto]

Hi Panini

No, I cannot take credit for developing the Key Lime Pie. I give that to those talented home cooks who managed to create a wonderful dessert with five ingredients and what was available locally. Those early Florida Keys residents were tough souls for sure-living with rain water from cisterns only, no air conditioning, little refrigeration and hurricanes! Having lived in Key West for three years without AC, I realized that summers are nice (no tourists), but September can be brutally hot and humid!

But what those cooks did with such simple ingredients is an American wonder!

Margarita pie is a nice dessert but I prefer a classic KLP. 

Real key limes are yellow, not green. In the keys, if you serve a green Key Lime Pie, they'll laugh you all the way back to Georgia!

 

[panini]

foodnfoto :Real key limes are yellow, not green. In the keys, if you serve a green Key Lime Pie, they'll laugh you all the way back to Georgia!

Can you tell me how you really feel? LOL. LOL luv ya!

You have me thinking now. We do a light green to try to imitate the Margarita. Also to tell them apart, we offer both.

We use Nelly and Joes in the gallon, but that has sporadic lately. If I can't get it we just 86.