Cooking Forum, Recipes & Pro Chef Tips - ChefTalk banner
21 - 40 of 48 Posts
Hi there! I am so glad to have found this thread. I have made macarons over the course of a year, and have produced all different results. Recently, I have mastered the meringue, mixing, piping and have beautiful, chewy, soft macarons with perfect feet. EXCEPT, they have very soft and delicate shells. I have tried everything to get the egg shell crust, but I can't figure out what I am doing wrong. I have tried 6 different recipes, and I have the same results. I've tried oven temperatures from 280 all the way to 375. I've tried parchment, silpat, double stacked cookie sheets and single cookie sheets. I'm going banana's and my husband has umm gained a lot of weight from all the macarons I have been making. Don't get me wrong, they are still delicious and do not go to waste, but it drives me banana's I can't get them 'perfect'. I even took a macaron class because I was desperate to figure out what I was doing wrong,  but not to discredit the chef, he wasn't exactly an expert. When the class broke into teams, I may or may not have steam rolled my team and did the whole thing. Wouldn't you know, beautifully perfect macaron. I could have cried! I went home, immediately tried to repeat, and same result as always. Thin shell. My husband describes a "true" macaron as looking very matte and mine are a little transparent. If that makes sense. I would appreciate any help!
 
That would make me a bit crazy too.


I get it about the domes...too fragile and the cookie is impossible to fill without crushing.


Are you using all the same brands as the class provided?


If so I would point to the only variable which is your oven.


You said you played with the temps but do you have thermometers in there?


I have 3 scattered about.


There may be hot spots or even dead spots.


Is the heat coming from a bottom or a top source?



mimi



Are you aging your whites?


Important step...relaxes the protein chains....



m.
 
Thanks for the reply! I did recently purchase an oven thermometer. I always suspected my oven ran hot, and I was right. It's 30 degree's too hot.

I made another batch last night. I paid careful attention to my meringue and macaronage. I watched a couple youtube videos and read a few blogs that showed properly mixed macaron, just to be sure I was not over mixing. I whip my merinque to firm, glossy peaks. I've read conflicting recipes on what stage to take the meringue. I think I take mine just shy of "bird peak". But if you held the bowl upside down, the meringue won't fall out. It clumps beautifully in the whisk.

I preheated the oven for an hour. The temperature on the stove was 265 but the thermometer (which I moved to 3 places) was 300. At least it is consistently too hot! I baked the first batch on a single tray for 15 minutes, and they had a fragile shell and slightly hollow. Next batch was a double tray for 18 minutes, the exactly same result except these started to brown. The third batch was a double tray with the oven door propped open with a wooden spoon (this was my first attempt at this technique) and they were completely hollow, the filling didn't even rise.

I took pictures of the first batch. I crushed the top of the shell with my fingers to show how delicate it is. I'm absolutely perplexed. I can't even get a firm shell with hollows! What am I doing wrong??

Preview of gallery image.

Preview of gallery image.

Here is my recipe...

125g almond meal (i've previously used blanched slivered almonds and ground them myself. the last several attempts, including this one, I used Bob's Red Mill almond meal)

225g powdered sugar

28g sugar

100g egg whites

For this attempt my egg whites were aged 3 days, I used less powdered sugar (200g) and used more sugar (40g) to see if the extra sugar would give me a more stabile meringue and the less powdered sugar would help it in some way. This was just based on cross referencing multiple recipes.

I'm beginning to wonder if it is in fact my oven. The heat source seems to be from the bottom only.

Thanks!!
 
Hello Chef,

Would you please email me the macaron template when you have a minute?

Do you have one for small and large macaron?

If you do,may I have both?

BTW, thank you for your post on macaron, it is very clear and detailed. Will try to make them next week (got to age the eggs, right?).

Thank you very much and have a great weekend

Ann
 
Thank you for your kind heart sharing your recipe!

I have hard time to make pure red color macaron shells. Which food colors I should combine to make really red? Since the meringue is always white, making strong colors is quite challenging for me!

I deeply appreciate your help!

Have a great day!

Warm regards,

Sam
 
IMO heavily saturated artificial colors leave a bitter aftertaste (esp red and black).
But...I can get a deeper red by adding freeze dried strawberry powder (mix in with the almond flour and 10X when grinding) then a few drops of a " no taste" red gel color at the end of the meringue stage with the flavoring.
There ya"ll have my last best secret tip.
Enjoy!

mimi
 
Hi, I've made successful French macarons before and this is my second attempt at Italian macarons. On both occasions, the egg whites refused to stiffen after pouring in the syrup :( The only thing I did differently from the recipe was to use a hand mixer instead of a stand mixer....any idea what went wrong?
 
Y
Hi, I've made successful French macarons before and this is my second attempt at Italian macarons. On both occasions, the egg whites refused to stiffen after pouring in the syrup :( The only thing I did differently from the recipe was to use a hand mixer instead of a stand mixer....any idea what went wrong?
Was the power of your hand mixer strong enough to achieve the stiff and shiny peak stage?
If not you may want to invest in one of the heavy duty stand mixers.
I use the KA 600 at home and find it adequate for just about anything I throw at it.

mimi
 
Barb.... there are a ridiculous number of templates to choose from if you type into your search engine.
All sizes and shapes and numbers per sheet.
Of course you will need to take one of those and make your own "custom" template that will fit whatever size sheets you use.
Mine are traced with a sharpie marker on cardboard (ink sinks in and dries without danger of bleeding).
The black one is really easy to see thru parchment paper.

mimi
 
Hi Chef Joey,

I have just made my very first batch of Italian macarons.

Preview of gallery image.

My question is why the structure of the feet are different. The ones on the left bulges out instead of rising upright (like those on the right).

I piped all the batter in one go and left them out to dry but baked the ones on the right first (i.e. first piped, first bake)

They were all baked at 145 degree Celsius for 13 minutes.

Could they reason be that the shells on the left were "left out too long"? Appreciate your advice.

Thank you and regards, Tracey
 
Your macarons look delicious! The specific instructions and detailed advice really came in handy./img/vbsmilies/smilies/smile.gif Would you recommend adding the seeds scraped from a fresh vanilla bean to the macaron batter (not the filling); would this change the texture too much?
 
Hi Thymetobake,

I have added both scraps from dried vanilla bean pods and vanilla bean powder into the macaron mixture/batter and the texture was not compromised.

From my experience, as long as the additions are dried (eg. freeze dried fruit powder, vinegar powder etc) the texture will

remain intact. However, do be very careful about adding wet ingredients such as fruit puree, as the chances of failure of the macaron cookie

baking properly is very high.

Hope that helps. Let me know how it turns out.

Regards, Tracey

P/s : I have baked a lot of macarons since my last posting in July 2014 (which btw, no one replied!).... sigh!

 
Hi Chef Joey,

May I know how to get in touch with your via Facebook?

I have been experimenting with a few macaron recipes and they inevitably produces different results.

Hence I would like to seek your assistance into the scientific reasons behind them.

I started baking macarons (very intensively I might add!) since end of July 2014 and is planning on going for a few

classes in Paris this December 2014. Is there any particular baking schools that you might recommend? I am particularly

interested in the making / piping of 3D character macarons.

Thanks,

Tracey

Attached are some photos of my work to-date.



 
Hi Chef, thank you for sharing your recipe. I just wonder if this recipe and method work well for big batch. In our hotel, we always do roughly around 5 to 6 times of your recipe and we can never seem to produce consistent macarons, sometimes they turn up good, sometimes they don't. We never have any problem with smaller batch (around 1,2kg tpt) but we cannot afford to make small batches all the time due to the demand. We have been trying out different recipes and methods but nothing really works. So I just want to ask if you have used this recipe for big batches and if the method is still the same? Thank you.
 
21 - 40 of 48 Posts